Back to News
Advertisement
Advertisement

⚑ Community Insights

Discussion Sentiment

67% Positive

Analyzed from 343 words in the discussion.

Trending Topics

#software#going#every#before#built#development#wayland#bugs#won#keep

Discussion (12 Comments)Read Original on HackerNews

shrubbleβ€’about 1 hour ago
Good to see that there is still development going on, a year after the fork on it. I don't view the love for Wayland as requiring deprecation of X11 or vice versa.
zuzululuβ€’about 1 hour ago
surprised that its getting active dev to this day

its sad that it doesn't get as much attention commercially

superdiskβ€’about 1 hour ago
Fwiw this post seems to have gotten nuked off the front page (and all subsequent pages). Not sure why.
calvinmorrisonβ€’about 1 hour ago
So I have been kind of idly watching this, trying to avoid the political. Every few days i jump in, do a git pull and look at commits. Over time I have been pasting them into the IRC and chatting about it. Some are clearly like 'wow this is an obvious fix' to bugs that seem to have been long standing. papercut type bugs. Some are larger refactors and clean ups that someone who is putting a project to bed wouldn't bother with. I also think Xorg is basically going into apache office mode, where they won't release, and patches keep piling up a-la the whole Go-OO debacle.

So I am glad to see the momentum, the cleanups, and most of all, the continued dedication to a GUI interface I have used since before I ever came to this country, before I even knew what X was, before I was married or my children were alive.

stop reading here if you wish

Politically, I think the engineering employees of professional and dedicated companies can develop and design intelligent, well built and excellent software. As much as we won't admit, Microsoft is/was a good example of being able to build and ship software. Likewise there are teams of people employed to work on Linux display systems. They have bosses. Their bosses are interested in certain things, and fund others. I think fracturing is not a bad idea. the 'Wayland' or 'Freedesktop' or maybe 'Fedora/intel/whatever employee' team also controlling X11 development is not healthy for either. Not to say I think overlap is bad, but I do believe - for me personally, given all the software I use every day is built on X11, it is important for me to keep it going, even if it's not politically expedient.

Thanks!

nixosbestosβ€’about 1 hour ago
> given all the software I use every day is built on X11

Oh? I'm curious what that is? Must be very old and/or bespoke :P

calvinmorrisonβ€’about 1 hour ago
my UI workflows like i3 and dmenu, but things like a systray for moc my music player. The desktop enviroment i use (KDE3.5) is also on top so Konqueror, Kmail, etc. glue scripts and small guis i have for i3 and dmenu that give me what i need, without a rewrite. emoji insert scripts i wrote for fun, random stuff you know it just works.