Speaking for the Dead

NNaOH 5 days ago 4 commentsRead Article on longreads.com

⚡ Community Insights

Discussion Sentiment

50% Positive

Analyzed from 95 words in the discussion.

Discussion (4 Comments)Read Original on HackerNews

pazimzadeh•18 minutes ago

I thought this would at least mention 'Speaker for the Dead' by Orson Scott Card somewhere?

thataccount•5 days ago

This is not speaking "for". It is speaking "about". About is always someone else's job to perform. "For" would be writing it up yourself, and handing it someone else to read.

AdamN•42 minutes ago

If an activist speaks up about a group of people being marginalized, they're speaking 'for' those people. 'About' would be if it was descriptive speaking (perhaps an anthropologist's article) but if it's in support of those people than 'for' is the right word.

BTW the object doesn't need to be people, it could also be animals or the environment or even abstract ideas like liberty or justice.

Tomte•about 1 hour ago

That‘s wrong. Speaking for someone means from their point of view, and it ususally implies a moral permission to do so.