Advertisement
Advertisement
⚡ Community Insights
Discussion Sentiment
71% Positive
Analyzed from 1494 words in the discussion.
Trending Topics
#syria#corrupt#years#religious#sharaa#syrian#before#government#own#don
Discussion Sentiment
Analyzed from 1494 words in the discussion.
Trending Topics
Discussion (22 Comments)Read Original on HackerNews
> Born in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, to a Syrian Sunni Muslim family from the Golan Heights, he grew up in Syria's capital, Damascus. Al-Sharaa joined al-Qaeda in Iraq shortly before the 2003 U.S. invasion of Iraq and fought for two years in the Iraqi insurgency. From 2005 to 2011, he was captured and imprisoned by American and Iraqi forces. His release coincided with the onset of the Syrian revolution against the Ba'athist regime of Bashar al-Assad. In 2012, with the support of al-Qaeda's central command, al-Sharaa founded Jabhat al-Nusra, also known as al-Nusra Front, to depose the Assad regime.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ahmed_al-Sharaa#Split_from_al-...
You have to jog to keep up with politics in the Middle East.
That whole region is a real fucking shame. Iran, Syria, Lebanon, they all could've been doing at least as well as Turkey if history had taken a different path.
Sunni Muslims perceive any external threat to their tribe as a parallel threat to Islam and a provocation to incite Jihad. Tribalism is what drives them.
The man is dangerous, because to reach his goals, it doesn’t matter if he lives or dies, only if the tribe continues, and he is very well aware of that.
It never works to let people like Al-Sharaa or Sinwar live and try to instrumentalise them for your own goals.
The Israelis thought they could handle Sinwar after releasing him from prison.
He taught them a lesson they are never going to forget, and while all the Mossad and IDF commanders’ names will never be said again five years after they are dead, people will still read up on Sinwar in hundreds of years and take the stuff that works and implement it into their own fight against insertrandomenemy here.
I am confident the man died laughing because he had already won. His survival was never a condition to reach his Goals. You can not imagine how dangerous this mindset is until you had to shoot a sixteen years old boy because he kept running at you with an explosives vest at a checkpoint.
The Americans think they can control Shaara aka Abu Mohammed al-Golani. I think they can’t. And I think we are all going to have to pay the price for it sooner or later.
It’s true, the man reinvented himself to be perceived as a charismatic leader. He looks pretty slick in his suit.
Personal reinvention, however, is not the same as institutional transformation.
The clever question to ask is, does the governing system consolidating in Damascus reflect a break from Golani’s earlier framework, or its realisation?
The evidence points clearly to continuity. Before assuming formal state authority, Golani outlined a political order grounded in religious legitimacy, hierarchical inclusion, and phased consolidation.
Today, executive authority is concentrated, religious oversight is embedded in lawmaking, and security institutions are structured around ideological alignment. Alternative centres of sovereignty are absorbed or dismantled.
Syria’s trajectory becomes clear when measured against the institutional framework its current president articulated as a jihadist years before taking office. What Golani once described as an insurgent now operates through state institutions.
The wolf has put on a sheep’s coat and is now constructing the kind of state he always wanted to construct, one where it doesn’t matter who rules it, because he embeds the same philosophy that brought war and terror to most parts of the world into the heads of the Syrian people with American money through governmental institutions.
It’s not the region that is a real fucking shame. It’s the way America produces warzones to feed young American souls into the machine the US is running on. War is a business, and the United States of America is the biggest manufacturer of war on the planet.
Syria will just be another showroom to sell other countries advanced weaponry made in the USA in 15 years.
He joined Al-Qaida when he was young, during the US invasion of Iraq, and spent years in a US prison where he grew his network, link to a particular faction of Al-Qaida that isn't that religious (ok, Islam is weird and way too hard to explain in a digression, let's leave it at 'not that religious' to avoid a 500 lines tunnel).
Kurds were extremely skeptical at first, but it seems at least some are happy with how things are proceeding (they are more involved than expected in drafting the new constitution that will take place in 2030).
It might sadly go to a dual government like Iran use to have before 2026, which is hurting my atheist self, but let's be honest, a dual government in the region is way, way more democracy than expected.
Even when they later go on to create terrorist organizations such as Jabhat al Nusra (Al Nusra Front). Boys will be boys.
Even when he got sent to Syria by Al Qaedas AQI (Which later became ISIS)
It baffles me that people like you justifies this man as a legitimate leader. Kurds and other minorities in Syria suffer immensely from this US and Turkish-forced government.
Why don't you tell the people of HN about the absolute massacre and manhunt of thousands of Alawites after Al-Julani came to power in Syria?
Also the Kurd I know have family in the Hatay province and around idil, so he is _very_ confident that economically at least it will be a success.
And like I said elsewhere, you can see the Turkish/ottoman Sunni influence in his religion (in islam culture and religion are extremely close), which is a very good sign. And concerning the massacre: we mostly forgot about Smyrna, and even Dersim isn't cited when we talk about AtatĂĽrk (both at least one order of magnitude bigger). It is very sad, but at the time European powers wanted stability in the area, and AtatĂĽrk gave them that. I only wish for the war to end and to have the area stabilise, and unlike Iran or even Irak, I see a slight chance that that it might end correctly for the minorities (10%?). Which isn't much, but I would rather wait a year or two before casting judgment.
I returned to Syria recently and so did 2 millions in the past 2 years. The country is doing better relatively speaking. It's not a first world country but most people have food and safety, and there's aid organizations to help those in need.
There's no conflation in priorities. Every bit helps. People are trying to start businesses and rebuild the country but this tech blockade contribute to making life harder unnecessarily.
They got promoted and de-sanctioned precisely because they are corrupt and worse, actual terrorists.
They're already literally Al-Qaeda islamist terrorists. Imagine if, moreover, they were also corrupt.
Rotten to the core doesn't begin to describe such individuals. They've got buddies at the helm in Iran: they slaughtered 30 000 unarmed civilians and publicly hung athletes... In January 2026.
Wonderful people.
Their values may be garbage, but that's tangential.
Also culturally, Syrian are very close to Turks and benefitted a lot from ottoman administration and Sunni legalism, which is a big reason why I believe it is possible for them to have a (mostly) secular government. Sadly I think it is likely they will implement a dual government like Iran had, a theocracy with a democratically elected secular government. Which are more resilient, but bad news overall (still better than Assad regime tbh).
Citation and some kind of proof needed here. It is very dubious proposition.
> because within their in-groups they're scoring each other based on those ideals
Their ideals dont tend to be "transparency, anti-corruption and fairness". Those three tend to be fairly low on the list of ideals they score each other on. For example, Iranian regime is considered very corrupt.
> they're not gonna behave like Saddam and just light money on fire for their own flamboyant luxury.
That is just a matter of aesthetics. Not a measure of coruption.