Back to News
Advertisement
Advertisement

⚡ Community Insights

Discussion Sentiment

75% Positive

Analyzed from 569 words in the discussion.

Trending Topics

#around#years#probably#lion#cave#downtime#https#www#lions#show

Discussion (18 Comments)Read Original on HackerNews

comrade1234about 2 hours ago
I had a project at the Smithsonian's conservation analytical laboratory in the later 90s and made friends with a girl working in the lab that was working on these: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/251028779_Three_lat...

(The timing is right at least and the lead author is from the Smithsonian)

She probably shouldn't have but she let me hold them in my hands. You could see that they were made by stuffing a skull with grass then putting the clay over the skull - you could see the grass imprints on the inside. I think they were from 9000 BC, Syria region. Pretty much brand new compared to this lion.

thisisauseridabout 2 hours ago
The Eurasian Cave Lion was around there back then and was probably the direct model for the Lion-man sculpture. It was roughly 20% larger than modern African lions. Paleolithic cave paintings (e.g., Chauvet) show the male cave lions lacked the heavy neck manes of modern lions.
fishfasellabout 1 hour ago
Been reading "Sapiens: A Brief History of Humankind", this piece is mentioned as the earliest proof of the Cognitive Revolution that we know of. It displays how humans were able to envisions things that do not exist, crafting fiction from reality. How early man was able to share stories and how religions probably came to be.
argee39 minutes ago
Isn't that begging the question? For one, people can wear a lion headdress, making it something that does exist in real life. Secondly, it seems to be carved from a single tusk, which might have forced some choices when it comes to anatomy, rather than being "as conceived".
wpollockabout 1 hour ago
> ... so why would a community living on the edge of subsistence, whose primary concerns were finding food, keeping that fire going, protecting children from predators, allow someone to spend so much time away from those tasks?

One possibility that occurs to me is the carving was done by the elderly, the injured, or possibility the young, who would not have such duties. A carving by a shaman is another possibility.

bee_rider13 minutes ago
I think it doesn’t really need much explaining anyway. Just from their example, 2/3 of those tasks (keeping the fire going and protecting from predators) required just… being awake and reasonably alert. I mean you could spend the time sitting around the fire making arrows (or spears or whatever, not sure what they had in year 40k BC), but maybe they ran out of nice stones to sharpen.

Probably most of us would not want to trade places with a substance hunter/gatherer, but their lives had downtime, right? I would expect their lives to be punctuated by good downtime (got enough food to eat and a good supply of tools, time to relax) as well as bad downtime (wasn’t successful at hunting or gathering, ran out of resources to process).

chmod77524 minutes ago
The idea that our hunter-gatherer ancestors were running around 16 hours a day with no downtime is a fantasy to begin with. They had more leisure time than early farmers and many Americans[1]

[1] https://www.nature.com/articles/s41562-019-0614-6

edelbitterabout 1 hour ago
That question does not require any greater explanation than "there was little else to be done, besides waiting for the storm to subside".
harryloveabout 1 hour ago
40k years from now, a hominid excavates a computer and materializes a login page in the ether. "We think they used this for ritual sacrifice or to brush their teeth or both."
wpollockabout 1 hour ago
You might enjoy the book "The Weans" by Robert Nathans, <https://www.goodreads.com/en/book/show/2664067-the-weans>
WalterGR8 minutes ago
And Motel of the Mysteries by David Macaulay, published in 1979. I read it as a kid and recall enjoying it.
clickety_clackabout 1 hour ago
It appears to be a primitive game where the user tries to guess which of 9 images contains “traffic lights” or “motorcycles” (whatever they are).
andsoitis2 days ago
Between 35,000 and 41,000 years old. Germany.
orsenthil44 minutes ago
TIL that Humans have been around for more than 40,000 years! I thought we started around 1000s of BC.
wewewedxfgdf6 minutes ago
A 67,800-year-old hand stencil was discovered in a limestone cave on Muna Island in Sulawesi, Indonesia

The Madjedbebe rock shelter in the Australian Northern Territory show that people lived in Australia at least 65,000 years ago where stone tools, ground ochre for paint, and food remains were found.

Carrok24 minutes ago
More than 300,000 years.
user00005about 1 hour ago
Hello I'm interested in buying. Do you still have original box?
ebbiabout 1 hour ago
Box disintegrated in the rain, but product is in fair used condition for its age.