Back to News
Advertisement
Advertisement

⚡ Community Insights

Discussion Sentiment

72% Positive

Analyzed from 1753 words in the discussion.

Trending Topics

#spirit#more#airlines#fuel#airline#prices#flights#probably#cost#down

Discussion (75 Comments)Read Original on HackerNews

instagib4 minutes ago
Management chased every quarter with little care about the long term future.

Took their profits and ran to other low cost airlines like frontier to make them ultra low cost per friends in the industry.

Spirit tried to merge a few times but failed due to their balance sheets. Then bankruptcy protections.

Follow the price of oil and airlines run into issues during those times when it goes above $100.

pfannkuchenabout 4 hours ago
> Winding Down

> To our Guests: all flights have been cancelled, and customer service is no longer available

That seems quite a bit stronger than “winding down”!

Animatsabout 3 hours ago
Just a few hours ago, Spirit execs were saying everything is just fine. At noon yesterday, Trump was saying that a bailout was still likely. (The first time I read about Trump saying that "we" were going to buy Spirit, I thought he meant him personally, or The Trump Organization. Spirit only needed about $500 million, and Trump could afford that.) That nobody wanted to buy a major airline for $500M means it was a really bad deal and not worth saving. They were already in Chapter 11 bankruptcy, the "debtor in possession" reorganization mode. Not yet clear if they just went to Chapter 7, liquidation, but that's probably happening within days.

Still, a zero-notice shutdown is a bit much. Some people who have tickets for tomorrow probably went to bed already.

There's still the mechanics of winding down. All the planes have to be flown to suitable storage locations. With such an abrupt shutdown, they'll have mis-positioned aircraft all over their route system. Many planes are probably leased, so the lessor may have to arrange to take custody of the aircraft. It's probably better if the aircraft are leased - there's some lessor with funds to take care of the job and the knowledge of how to arrange it, since a handover and move happens at the end of each aircraft lease. Aircraft Spirit actually owns will have to be moved by a bankruptcy receiver, which is a lawyer trying to run what's left of an airline. Most major airports charge very high parking fees. LAX charges $1000 for the first day, and that goes up to $5000 a day on day four. They're not in the storage business.

There are probably a lot of middle of the night phone calls and meetings going on right now.

gucci-on-fleek40 minutes ago
> Most major airports charge very high parking fees. LAX charges $1000 for the first day, and that goes up to $5000 a day on day four.

That seems pretty cheap to me actually. A random Google search suggests that an airplane costs at least $100MM, so $5k per day is 0.005% of the airplane's value.

Scaled down proportionally to a $100k car, that's only $5 per day, and considering that many parking lots charge $5 per hour, that seems like a pretty good deal.

barneyboorooabout 3 hours ago
It's "orderly", don't you know!
shawn_wabout 3 hours ago
It was a very quick wind down.
testfrequencyabout 3 hours ago
More like a free fall ffs
sudo_cowsayabout 3 hours ago
It's a fall down. Just like their stock prices.
clintonbabout 3 hours ago
It’s strange to see so many commenters celebrating the death of a company and the loss of so many jobs.

I flew Spirit a few times. The first time sucked because it was an emergency and I had no other option. The last few flights were great. We got the large seats up front for $75 extra. That plus parking at SJC was still cheaper than flying Southwest out of OAK.

The staff were friendly, and the gate was conveniently across from a lounge, so we had a truly great experience for those couple flights to Dallas.

spacedcowboyabout 1 hour ago
It's probably the association with Trump, at least to those outside the US. Anything even remotely connected to that arsehole is, almost by definition, to be reviled. If he wanted to save it, there's probably a really good reason not to, without reading any further into the topic.
user_7832about 3 hours ago
Can someone explain to me (a non American) which niche or segment was Spirit in (and perhaps why they, and not any other airline, are shutting shop)?
meyabout 3 hours ago
Low cost carrier. Think Ryanair. Competition from the rest of the market and bad management put them in a bad position, with the most recent war causing unsustainable fuel issues. Other airlines may be able to double/triple their prices in the short term. Spirit's customers may simply choose to not fly.

https://www.npr.org/2026/05/02/nx-s1-5807933/spirit-airlines... describes this in more detail.

infinitewarsabout 3 hours ago
Similar to Ryanair in Europe
plantainabout 3 hours ago
Good. They treated their customers terribly and actions have consequences. I was double charged for a flight and they just refused to acknowledge it until I charged back, after which I assume they banned me.
livinglistabout 2 hours ago
That’s my experience of every single US airline though…
aliljetabout 3 hours ago
Why did Spirit die? Was there any last of this that had to do with their abysmal customer service?
Ekarosabout 3 hours ago
Airlines are not great business. Margins are not great. Fuel is significant part of their operating costs. And if it goes up too much in too short time the whole model breaks. Less margins you have the more you will be impacted. So if you are operating at edge by default fast move in costs will destroy you.
gib444about 3 hours ago
IAG in 2025 had a record operating margin of 15.1%.

Ryanair's gross profit margin for fiscal years ending March 2021 to 2025 averaged 19.1%.

Some are (were?) doing just fine - in Europe at least.

Sure, it's no Big Tech or banking, but it's not like the single low digit percentage of eg retail.

Perhaps some USA airlines need some advice from across the pond?

Wurdanabout 2 hours ago
The business model works fundamentally differently in the US and Europe due to geography. The US is big, meaning that flights are often longer, meaning that fuel is a bigger portion of the operating cost. And fuel is essentially something airlines can’t reduce the cost of compared to other operating costs where it might be possible to optimize for greater efficiency.
matwoodabout 2 hours ago
The immediate cause was rising fuel prices. The other issue sounds like it was poorly ran.

More generally, it is also a low cost carrier at a time when, after years of competing on price, airlines are seeing people willing to pay more for a better experience. All other carriers are expanding their premium options, catering to the affluent part of the K economy (for the first time ever the majority of Delta revenue came from premium cabins over main). Meanwhile, Spirit was dealing on the other side of the K who is also most impacted by increasing inflation, etc... giving Spirit zero ability to raise prices.

gib444about 1 hour ago
> Meanwhile, Spirit was dealing on the other side of the K who is also most impacted by increasing inflation, etc... giving Spirit zero ability to raise prices.

Ryanair (Europe's biggest and most profitable airline) is managing it OK [0]

What's difference about that side of the K in the USA vs Europe?

[0] https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c620506dvmjo

avazhiabout 3 hours ago
Is this your first time on the internet since February?
gblarggabout 2 hours ago
Some of us don't consume the mainstream news and don't fly.
avazhiabout 2 hours ago
If you didn't know about the war in Iran and the effects it has had on oil and thus jet fuel prices, I'm not sure what you're doing on HN.
robin_realaabout 3 hours ago
Small regional airline failing isn’t a big news story in my typical parts of the internet.
avazhiabout 3 hours ago
No, Spirit is/was not a 'small regional'.

You asked if this was caused by or related to bad customer service. This was 100% caused by the increase in jet fuel prices due to the war in Iran. Obviously huge swings in jet fuel prices affect budget carriers more than, say, United or American or Lufthansa or Singapore Airlines, which have many (many) more options when jet fuel prices rise.

Many countries, including many third world countries, have regional airlines. It has nothing to do with America in particular, and the usage of that term is not an American-ism. A good non-American example is Qantas and QantasLink, the latter being a regional airline, and the Aussies refer to it as such.

epistasisabout 4 hours ago
This process may seem ugly, but just like biological death is necessary for an ecosystem, this sort of death/restructuring is essential for capitalist economies. Assets and capital get reallocated to better uses. It's all part of the circle of life.
gizmo686about 3 hours ago
Bankcruptcy and corporate death in general are important. However, the details of how that is managed can vary wildly, and not all implementations are equal.

In this case, the bankcruptcy was handled by cancelling all flights with 1 day of notice. This level of ugliness is not necessary.

matwoodabout 3 hours ago
“How did you go bankrupt? Two ways. Gradually, then suddenly.” -Hemmingway
system7rocksabout 3 hours ago
Thank God human beings who spend money on these resources are left to fend for themselves. Imagine if we spent good money on a flight, and now the company winds down its operations even as we are on route to our destination. Since we are just a number, I supposed we should simply cease to exist or occupy a liminal space. Or maybe... we could be treated as a human being?
ozgrakkurtabout 3 hours ago
Ideally, they should have stopped selling tickets and then stopped the flights when the sold flights were done. At least within some time frame like 1 month
Kwpolskaabout 2 hours ago
I doubt many people would buy tickets for a flight with a failing airline. That said, shutting down with effectively zero notice is pretty terrible, and they will probably need to do a bunch of repositioning flights, so they could have kept the lights on for one or two more days.
ozgrakkurtabout 1 hour ago
I agree with this.

I initially meant that they should have finished the flights they already sold tickets for, in some timeframe like one month.

Changed the phrasing so it is more clear.

V99about 3 hours ago
Unfortunately continuing to burn money with no hope of recovery is not a popular strategy among judges and creditor's lawyers. Customers will either get refunds or join the back of the creditor line.
noosphrabout 3 hours ago
looks at ai investments

Sure.

project2501aabout 3 hours ago
Comment is made after May 1st, international strike day.
doogliusabout 3 hours ago
> biological death is necessary for an ecosystem

Can you expand on this? How do you explain e.g. ecosystems around centuries-old redwoods?

matwoodabout 3 hours ago
Interesting example since giant sequoias benefit greatly from forest fires...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sequoia_sempervirens#Fire_adap...

danarisabout 3 hours ago
In addition to the human cost that others mention, the big problem is that in our current system, this doesn't lead to fresh blood coming in and being able to compete on an even footing: it leads to the giant incumbents schlorping up the pieces and becoming even bigger and stronger.

Your statement might be true in a system with healthy safeguards ands competition, but that isn't the system we have in the real world today.

pjmlpabout 3 hours ago
Sure, for those not affected by these capitalist decisions, left stranded in the middle of nowhere, or having to look for a new job, while the owner party at their coffy houses.
vrganjabout 3 hours ago
That sounds more like religious dogma than thought out argument.

The capital will probably go to further the AI bubble, I really don't see how that would be more useful than enabling travel.

riffraffabout 3 hours ago
While it's fair to criticize how this screwed up customers (and perhaps workers), airline shutdowns are often good things, route/airport slots gets freed for example, and airlines with better value (cost or quality wise) can take over.

I don't live in the US but spirit has been the butt of jokes for years.

wg0about 3 hours ago
Seems like the fallout of the unnecessary adventurism in middle east.
phtrivierabout 2 hours ago
The article does not give context : it is not entirely about the price of fuel, but it seems like fuel was the last nail in the coffin...
muppetmanabout 3 hours ago
Wow those Halloween shops really flopped huh?
intothemildabout 3 hours ago
If only they flapped. Maybe they'd still be in the air.
rvzabout 4 hours ago
Too bad. Capitalism working as it should and no last minute government bailouts for failing companies.

The market should decide and determines winners and losers, not the government.

So compete.

phtrivierabout 3 hours ago
I never heard about this company before this morning, so I can't project any second order effect of this closure.

That being said, I suspect many people had never heard about Lehman Brothers before 2008...

47282847about 4 hours ago
low_tech_loveabout 3 hours ago
Man wouldn’t it be great if we lived in that world?
vrganjabout 3 hours ago
Other than ideology, in what way is this a good outcome? For passengers? For workers?
ungreased0675about 2 hours ago
Because companies that are run poorly should go out of business. Otherwise, what incentive is there for management to do a good job?
vrganjabout 2 hours ago
Why can't management be fired instead? Why punish the above groups for the mistakes of leadership?
littlexsparkeeabout 3 hours ago
can't help but think of the deadweight loss to the US over lack of free market capitalism in terms of bailouts, price supports & subsidies, monopolies, etc. every day we stray further and further from this system we purport to have.

edit: do folks not think more competition would be better for consumers? i'm no stan of capitalism but surely it could be made better, sheesh.

Advertisement
xystabout 3 hours ago
I sense another bailout for the airline industry if the illegal Iran war continues. Spirit is just the first domino to fall.
system7rocksabout 3 hours ago
I am so grateful for this announcement. In a time when gas prices are high, Spirit should be the kind of capitalist example that dominates. Instead, it goes bankrupt despite the President trying to nationalize it. Thanks be to the God of money.