Kraftwerk's radical 1976 track

ainch•about 1 hour ago

I love Kraftwerk, but contributing to anti-nuclear sentiment in Germany hasn't been a major success. If only more European countries had followed the French example and developed substantial nuclear fleets.

kingleopold•about 1 hour ago

coal kills more people, this is a fact. so with blocking nuclear lead to coal, so they indirectly supportered killing thousands, incredible stats really. who said art can't be bad for the public?

pepa65•about 1 hour ago

What do you mean by "nuclear fleets"??

msla•about 1 hour ago

Being against nuclear only kept the world on coal longer.

rectang•about 1 hour ago

And perhaps meaningfully contributed to a reduction in the quantity of radioactive waste products requiring custodianship on a timescale that humans can barely conceive of let alone commit to or execute responsibly.

mgfist•40 minutes ago

Coal power produces more radiation waste into the environment than nuclear power. That's because nuclear power has this amazing quality where all the waste is neatly packaged whereas burning coal just releases it into the air.

> requiring custodianship on a timescale that humans can barely conceive of let alone commit to or execute responsibly.

This is fearmongering. Casing waste in big concrete casks is enough. It's so incredibly overblown that we're willing to burn coal and kill people over it.

senectus1•about 1 hour ago

only if renewable resources are not considered an option.

WatchDog•about 2 hours ago

If the suggested political impact of this music is to be believed, the music might be one of the biggest environmental disasters of all time.

Germany has been pretty widely criticized for decommissioning it's nuclear power program, only to replace it with Russian oil.

lovemenot•about 2 hours ago

>> only to replace it with Russian oil

with Russian gas.

MomsAVoxell•about 1 hour ago

s/Russian/American/

Either way, Germany has perfected the efficient foot bullet, at least.

I could imagine Kraftwerk devising a stonkin’ “Fußkugel” track, actually ..

Barrin92•about 1 hour ago

that would be an odd criticism because we never generated any meaningful amount of electricity from oil (and started importing Russian fossil resources 30 years before we turned nuclear power plants off). The chief source for energy in Germany was coal. Gas is primarily an industry and heating input rather than a source of power generation, gas plants have only become more popular in recent years.

What replaced all other fossil fuel sources are renewables, which at 50% are now by far the single largest source of energy.

LeoPanthera•about 1 hour ago

The original version is quite different from the version performed today. The original lyrics refer to the pun of "radioactivity" versus "radio activity", meaning, activity on the radio.

The new live version refers almost exclusively to the former meaning, and adds "stop" to turn it into a protest song.

I've seen Kraftwerk live twice, at London's Albert Hall and Berkeley's Greek Theater, both times absolutely amazing. Highly recommended.

I've often thought they would be the ideal band to perform inside the "Sphere" in Las Vegas.

nntwozz•about 2 hours ago

Ruckzuck is way more interesting and ahead of its time (1970).

https://youtu.be/yUFc5QoMG1E

P.S

Also check out Ashra - Deep Distance (1976).

https://youtu.be/BJZ9PVvu9OA

alanwreath•about 2 hours ago

Only related in awesomeness but whenever I see VLC’s icon I think of Kraftwerk.

Kraftwerk sounds novel even today, I can’t imagine how it must have sounded 50 years ago.

the_arun•about 2 hours ago

IMHO Autobahn is still their best.

cmrx64•about 2 hours ago

The Electronic Harpsichord, same year. must have been an interesting time.

xgulfie•about 2 hours ago

saving you a click: it's Radioactivity

Kraftwerk's radical 1976 track

⚡ Community Insights

Discussion (17 Comments)Read Original on HackerNews