Back to News
Advertisement
Advertisement

⚡ Community Insights

Discussion Sentiment

77% Positive

Analyzed from 704 words in the discussion.

Trending Topics

#site#web#town#social#square#idea#old#sort#still#https

Discussion (19 Comments)Read Original on HackerNews

xuhu35 minutes ago
I hope sites that just provide a way for people to assemble offline will be the new thing soon.

A photography guide's site that rallies amateurs for walk tours. A planning board for a foreign language practice group. A site with a schedule and registration form for a sports event.

When I read "online social" my head thinks "not-really social".

SoftTalker41 minutes ago
Not sure how this is appealing at all. I see a bunch of stick figures moving rapidly and comments flashing too quickly to read. I gave up as it wasn't obvious at all what to do or how to particpate.
cauenapier36 minutes ago
The issue is that my site right now is too crowded giving this post reached a good position on HN.

On regular days, this are much calmer. You can check other sites using the Townsquare on cauenapier.townsquare.com. Check out the map.

graypeggabout 1 hour ago

    > The goal wasn't to build another social network.
    > It was to bring back a small feeling that the web used to have: the sense that there are actual people on the other side of the screen.
    > Town Square is intentionally tiny and forgetful. There are no accounts, no profiles, no follower counts, no permanent chat history. Messages exist only while people are there to read them.
Cute idea! But maybe this is just me having a different experience, but people having accounts/permanence was one of the defining “old web” feelings people keep talking about. A few people that were always in comment threads, or people with their own blogs linking back to you etc. People didn’t have the sign guestbooks with the same info every time, but they would anyway because they’re building up a persona. I get that you don’t want any social-media-y popularity contests, but… that is sort of what the web 30+ years ago was like.
cauenapierabout 1 hour ago
I'm actually thinking about implementing some sort of "permanence" for some people, specially for recurring visitors of a given site. But that's still an early thought.
graypegg27 minutes ago
Would that be a little guy permanently on the page even if the user isn’t present, or a permanent persona for a user across visits?
oceliker31 minutes ago
Reminds me of the old ff0000, sadly no longer active, but this is what it looked like: https://www.reddit.com/r/lost_websites/comments/11lao71/ff00...

I had found it on StumbleUpon. We'd log in with friends and just fly around, explore, punch each other, chat with random people across the world on a surprisingly fluid multiplayer setting that was built to promote a web advertising agency (if I remember correctly).

It was really ahead of its time. The old internet was so fun.

truemoose28 minutes ago
I love it, and I just want to say thanks for making this and releasing it. I jumped through the indieweb webring and already stumbled onto another site using it too. Despite what some others have said about the lack of permanence, this still feels like an old web treasure to me even if it didn't exist.
pflenker34 minutes ago
Reminds me of m favorite late 90s messenger, Odigo[0]. It had some sort of radar which showed you people who were visiting the same site. It sure had this town hall feel, but admittedly most sites were simply empty.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Odigo_Messenger

0xkistuabout 1 hour ago
Previously discussed: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48608570

Really love the idea!

peab20 minutes ago
This is awesome
thomastjefferyabout 1 hour ago
Fun!

People in a town square still have identities. They are just likely to not know each other.

I think this is a significant part of a great idea. What it, and most/all other communication software is missing, is the ability to continue a conversation into a new context. It would be great to move a convo from the public square into a shop, then maybe share contact info to get together another day.

FinnKuhn44 minutes ago
> People in a town square still have identities. They are just likely to not know each other.

I think that entirely depends on the size of the town. For a big city this is absolutely true, but in a small village you would expect to find at least a few familiar faces.

AndrewKemendoabout 1 hour ago
Fun! There’s a lot of features there to play with and it acts as a real time view counter.

Interestingly I used it then left without even reading the article

ranger_dangerabout 1 hour ago
Now this is cool! I'd love to see something like it on most web pages as a way to interact with like-minded people... but then I start thinking about all the ways it's going to be abused and get sad.
cauenapierabout 1 hour ago
I'm the site author and creator of TownSquare. The only moment it got a bit abused it was during the first HN spike. But before and after that, everything was friendly.
evnp30 minutes ago
Love this idea and your creation of it. Unfortunately do think the parent's concerns are valid - at this moment on your site at least one person has set their name to something offensive so it shows up perpetually (under the street light). Anonymity+connectivity persists in bringing out the worst of our impulses, I guess...

Do you think names are really necessary? Or could they take some other form than text, perhaps unicode chars chosen from a selection of abstract shapes? The wonderful https://www.tunera.xyz/fonts/teranoptia/ comes to mind.

nickradford15 minutes ago
teranoptia looks cool as hell, thanks for sharing!
Zak25 minutes ago
I think there might be some merit to a basic filter, perhaps some sort of timeout for obvious slurs. I see a few right now.
Advertisement