Back to News
Advertisement
Advertisement

⚡ Community Insights

Discussion Sentiment

100% Positive

Analyzed from 238 words in the discussion.

Trending Topics

#article#seems#claude#verification#test#month#days#korean#isn#design

Discussion (7 Comments)Read Original on HackerNews

akozakabout 3 hours ago
The source article in Korean actually seems to tell a somewhat different story, that it's been a massive productivity boost in their early experiments. You could focus on the points of friction, but that isn't the main takeaway I think.
wuschelabout 1 hour ago
I understand that they used Claude to create some sort of produced a verification code and test environments from circuit-design information, verification programs, and protocol specifications. But isn't precisely this quite risky due to the statitical nature of LLMs? I would have thought that they rather operate with very rigid test suites based on such software like F*, Coq, and whatnot.

Can someone with understanding of the process chime in here?

Here is the text snippet from the original korean article. Indeed the information was misrepresented:

"Customer-specific SoC verification work, which Usually takes Over a month, was completed in just two days. A second-year employee completed a USB model development that previously takes a month in a single day".

jvwwwabout 1 hour ago
Feels like a disingenuous heading for the article.

All of the problems they listed seem quite solvable. And it seems like it's saving a lot of time.

But saying AI is doing good doesn't generate the same number of clicks!

cyanydeezabout 3 hours ago
AI makes a great shotgun; occasional sniper.

But it is not a divine shotgun sniper rifle hybrid.

josefritzishereabout 3 hours ago
What could possibly go wrong?
dist-epochabout 3 hours ago
> Claude built a virtual test environment with placeholder blocks standing in for the missing RTL and started catching errors before the real design was even finished. Reportedly, this task would normally take over a month, but Claude managed to finish it in two days.

Seems a lot went quite right, traditional 30 day task done in 2 days

throwatdem12311about 2 hours ago
Surely this should help with the cost of the chips!

(/s)