AGPLv3§74 Empowers Users to Thwart Badgeware Like OnlyOffice

pwdisswordfishq•7 minutes ago

Hacker News is too good for pilcrows?

RobotToaster•about 2 hours ago

The fact that the addictional terms are basically designed to defeat the original licence should make it clear to anyone that it isn't a "reasonable legal notice".

IMO this is a great illustration of how the word "reasonable" stops the entire legal system collapsing.

roenxi•about 2 hours ago

This all seems a bit silly. Sneaky Company, Inc. can also add in that this new clause should be removed.

The problem here isn't the legal interpretation of the license and adding new clauses doesn't seem to do anything useful. Sneaky Company can license their software under whatever weird combination of terms they like. If they want GPL except it's proprietary then they can do that. Weird but ok. Same again if they want the license to be internally contradictory - seems stupid but they can do that too.

The actual issue is if they're trying to be deceptive by framing something as GPL licensed when in fact it is some new not-in-the-GPL-spirit license that they have developed. They should either be generally shamed or sued by whoever has copyright over the term "GPL" (pretty sure that is the FSF). That'd be ironic but there you go. Or some sort of false advertising suite.

pabs3•about 1 hour ago

FSF did the shame thing:

https://www.fsf.org/blogs/licensing/agpl-is-not-a-tool-for-t... https://lwn.net/Articles/1067771/

aniviacat•about 2 hours ago

First time I hear about Euro-Office. I wonder if that's a serious project or just fishing for EU funding.

edelbitter•28 minutes ago

This is much bigger than subsidies. IONOS is already making serious money in selling "we host FOSS for you" to both users and (though generally: small) companies. They can expect to gain substantially greater revenue from acquiring larger commercial and municipal/federal customers.. IF the full package attains sufficient interoperability to withstand the usual anti-competitive tactics.

moqmar•about 2 hours ago

Most of the companies behind it (including NextCloud itself & IONOS) are providing a document cloud to their users already & are used to maintaining Open Source, so I would indeed assume some seriousness here.

RobotToaster•about 1 hour ago

Both, I imagine

pseudalopex•about 2 hours ago

IONOS and Nextcloud are serious companies.

andrewshadura•about 2 hours ago

Quite clearly OnlyOffice never wanted to have a fully free software office suite. The (mis)use of AGPL has always been a marketing trick and nothing more.

odie5533•about 2 hours ago

Software wants to be free.

Software is like sex. It's better when it's free.

AGPLv3§74 Empowers Users to Thwart Badgeware Like OnlyOffice

⚡ Community Insights

Discussion (11 Comments)Read Original on HackerNews