Back to News
Advertisement
Advertisement

⚡ Community Insights

Discussion Sentiment

100% Positive

Analyzed from 429 words in the discussion.

Trending Topics

#water#air#based#article#don#wonder#stillsuit#dehumidifier#extra#steps

Discussion (31 Comments)Read Original on HackerNews

phyzix5761•3 minutes ago
I appreciate this style of writing. Straight to the point. No 12 paragraphs about someone's grandmother falling in love in Italy with a plastic bag.
erelong•20 minutes ago
I've heard of collecting water with tarps and assume this is like a vest form of that:

https://www.campingsurvival.com/blogs/camping-survival-blogs...

grugagag•40 minutes ago
This reminds me of Dune. Does this really work tho?
karim79•10 minutes ago
Assuming it's an "all-weather" jacket I think it would be cool for it to spout out umbrellas when it starts raining, batman style, to catch rain water as well and drop it into pouches. Mp3 player would be great as well.
johnnyApplePRNG•31 minutes ago
Incredible innovation.

Wouldn't want to be drinking whatever this produces in the GTA though lol

the__alchemist•about 2 hours ago
Nearly all passive water-from-air devices described in articles are based on false claims. Peltier-based, desiccant/absorption/adsorption based, etc. All end up not working, or not existing. This has been common for ~10 years.

Which category does this fall into?:

  - Fraud
  - Incompetence / misunderstanding that wasn't cleared up prior to publishing an article
  - Neither; this works as expected
donkers•about 1 hour ago
The design seems reasonable. It seems like a scaled down version of this MIT one that uses similar principles:

https://news.mit.edu/2025/window-sized-device-taps-air-safe-...

So my vote is for working as expected.

tentacleuno•about 1 hour ago
Many thanks for your link to the article, it was a very interesting read; fascinating to learn how glycerol interacts with lithium salts...
PLenz•about 2 hours ago
Makes sense since we're speedrunning the other parts of the Butlerian jihad
EarlKing•about 2 hours ago
I don't know about the rest of you, but if somebody spots Shai-hulud out in the Sahara I'm outta here.
kreelman•about 1 hour ago
At the end of Dune.... Chani is heartbroken... Needing to get away...

   Oh I'm a leavin' on a Shai-hulud
   Don't know when I'll be back again..
AnimalMuppet•about 2 hours ago
Out of here to where?
whynotmaybe•about 1 hour ago
Outside of the environment?
Loughla•about 1 hour ago
Honestly, bring on Leto II. Fuck it.
keithnz•about 2 hours ago
depending on actual conditions you are in, it could potentially double (or more) the time before you die of thirst if it was your only source of water.
brewdad•about 2 hours ago
I do wonder about the tradeoff between excess perspiration due to wearing heavier materials versus the ability to collect water, especially on the days where replenishing fluids is most crucial.
keithnz•about 1 hour ago
from what I can tell, you dont have to wear it?
loloquwowndueo•about 3 hours ago
My first thought was “yay a stillsuit” - but this grabs moisture from the air, not the wearer’s body. So no. No stillsuit yet.
Kurd•about 3 hours ago
Lisan al-Gaib!
ashton314•7 minutes ago
[delayed]
sanex•about 3 hours ago
Seconded. I wonder which would taste better though.
3eb7988a1663•about 3 hours ago
Would you want it? I thought you were supposed to urinate and defecate in the suit so as to maximally retain moisture.
g-b-r•about 3 hours ago
Just wear it in reverse ;)

A big step towards a stillsuit anyways ;)

b3ing•about 2 hours ago
I wonder if it has microplastics, but probably depends what kind of fabric was used
NopIdoN•about 1 hour ago
works in the rain
Advertisement
SadErn•about 3 hours ago
Vaporware has never tasted so good or been so refreshing.
elgertam•about 1 hour ago
Vaporwear*
jojobas•about 3 hours ago
This sort of thing can't work as it would break basic laws of thermodynamics. Best case it's a dehumidifier with extra steps.
donkers•about 2 hours ago
Why would it break the laws? Per the article it uses the heat from sunlight to do some of its work, it's not some kind of magic fabric.
jojobas•about 2 hours ago
So a dehumidifier with extra steps.
Supermancho•about 2 hours ago
"extra steps" meaning wearable dehumidifier. Are there other wearable dehumidifiers to produce drinking water? I don't think so.

A reductive assessment (to a specific feature) of a novel idea, does not make it less interesting.