What's the most popular number in Hacker News titles?

Xirdus•34 minutes ago

I really wish the analysis didn't cut off at exactly 10 numbers. Rerunning the query with higher LIMIT, I noticed the following:

- The very next two numbers are 100 and 0. While 100 is consistent with the article's explanations, 0 still placing high despite fixing the query warrants further investigation. A quick glance at returned headlines shows the problem of phantom zeroes is not, in fact, fixed.

- The query doesn't group decimals and integers together. 2.0 is at #17 with 10k hits, while 1.0 is at #26 with 5k hits. So not only is the "version number" explanation for top numbers wrong - the claim that earlier version numbers are more common than later version numbers is wrong too.

laurentlb•about 1 hour ago

Thanks for providing the query and a link to execute it (I didn't know about that one). Now I can play with it and find the most popular words...

"to", "the", "of". I don't know what I expected.

gregdaniels421•3 minutes ago

For determining words that are important doing something like a tf-idf would make more sense, or doing some key word analysis like RAKE or YAKE.

pm2222•about 2 hours ago

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Benford%27s_law

omgmog•about 2 hours ago

Yes, as linked in the post

benj111•12 minutes ago

My guess is 1 (or 1.0) declaring something has reached 'stable'

Edit. Perhaps the title should be 'parsing numbers is hard'.

jdw64•23 minutes ago

I once did some small work with a mathematician who was an online friend of mine. He was really into Benford's Law. A lot of mathematicians seem to love Benford's Law, and I wonder why that is. I'm not sure if I was rude to him, but we lost touch, and I miss him. I learned so much from his code.

rmunn•8 minutes ago

Probably because it's so useful in detecting the "smell" of fraudulent numbers. Fraud is, of course, going to be most common where money is involved, but it can show up in many other places: for example, someone might be tempted to fudge their scientific data if their career depends on getting numbers that aren't quite where they want the numbers to be...

If a number distribution that should be following Benford's Law isn't, that's nowhere close to actual proof of fraud, but it can be a pointer helping you know where to start looking. Because if all the files except this one have numbers that follow Benford's Law, yet this one doesn't, then that's the place where you start digging for other, more positive, evidence of manipulation.

jdw64•5 minutes ago

Thank you!

fghorow•about 2 hours ago

Probably 42, but I could be mistaken...

calvinmorrison•about 1 hour ago

We're number 1!

benfords law strikes again. useful for fraud analysis too

mwigdahl•about 2 hours ago

You missed a great opportunity to title this "The 10 most popular numbers in Hacker News titles"!

saghm•about 2 hours ago

You'll never guess number 6! Seriously, why would you think that 6 is one of them, there are so many better numbers out there

omgmog•about 2 hours ago

Now that's Numberwang!

What's the most popular number in Hacker News titles?

⚡ Community Insights

Discussion (14 Comments)Read Original on HackerNews