Swap, ZRAM, Zswap and Hibernate on NixOS

Discussion (5 Comments)Read Original on HackerNews

seabrookmx•36 minutes ago

I've had good luck using zswap+zstd on Ubuntu 26.04. I have a Framework 13 (AMD) with 16GB, and have a 16GB swap file configured (ext4 root partition).

I had planned to upgrade the machine to 32GB of RAM but I don't really feel it's necessary at this point. Which is obviously great given the current RAM costs!

gucci-on-fleek•about 3 hours ago

I agree with everything else here, but swap files on btrfs should probably be avoided whenever possible [0].

[0]: https://btrfs.readthedocs.io/en/latest/Swapfile.html

ciferkey•about 3 hours ago

Right, you are good to do swap files on btrfs since linux 5.0 or so as long as you follow some rules. Disko thankfully covers all those details for you, but I shouldn't have skipped over that in the piece. I'll make an update when I get a chance.

gucci-on-fleek•about 2 hours ago

Swap files work, but I wouldn't quite say "you are good to do swap files on btrfs" because the official documentation (the page I linked earlier) says

> filesystem - must be only single device

> This means swapfiles will have an amplified impact, much larger than the size of the swapfile itself.

> Users should be aware of the impact when using swapfiles alongside other data. This is especially discouraged for root filesystem.

If a swap file is the only thing that will work with your setup, then it's fine to use one, but if you're at all able to use a swap partition, then that's a far better choice. (Swap files are fine on ext4 and xfs; it's only COW filesystems like btrfs and zfs where they should be avoided.)

eccgecko•about 3 hours ago

Thanks for this. So weird though - I literally spent the better part of the weekend reading and learning all about the differences between zram and zswap and ultimately deciding to switch out my previous zram config for zswap on my NixOS system! So seeing this pop up on my hackernews feed felt a bit spooky…

Swap, ZRAM, Zswap and Hibernate on NixOS

⚡ Community Insights

Discussion (5 Comments)Read Original on HackerNews