Back to News
Advertisement
Advertisement

⚡ Community Insights

Discussion Sentiment

57% Positive

Analyzed from 552 words in the discussion.

Trending Topics

#electric#range#gas#hybrids#https#more#car#extended#volt#constant

Discussion (18 Comments)Read Original on HackerNews

gcanyon•about 2 hours ago
One thing that always puzzled me was how the gas engines in hybrids were so efficient. Technology Connections has a great video explainer: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KnUFH5GX_fI

tl;dw: constant RPM and a weird stroke geometry where the power stroke is longer than the other strokes to extract more energy from the expanding gasses.

jostmey•about 2 hours ago
I'm surprised there isn't more effort to create hybrids in reverse--an electric car with optional gas generator. The gas generator could run at constant speed, never changing RMP, while the battery handles constant changes in acceleration. The idea is not mine. I've heard about it in China
meyum33•6 minutes ago
It seems to me you’re talking about a range extender, which lots of Chinese EV makers use. Many do buy them but sometimes you get the worst of both worlds: weighty like an EV and the heat, vibration, exhaust of a petro car. For most people the extended range is only needed very occasionally but you have to carry the ICE system the whole time.
ehnto•21 minutes ago
That is exactly what ePOWER is, that configuration is called a series hybrid and is more commonly seen in heavy industry like diesel trains or trucks in the mines (for better or worse).

More recently effort is also going into series hybrids for public road haulers, which I personally think is a great application for it since you can potentially put a lot of the equipment into a hot-swappable dolly.

I drove a Nissan Note (Nismo esition) with ePower and it could happily spin the wheels when taking off, not something you normally get out of a tiny economy hatchback. I think it has 140kw electric drivetrain? 140kw is pretty sporty when delivered instantly.

sjtrny•about 1 hour ago
Twirrim•about 1 hour ago
The volt was never popular enough, unfortunately. Right around the time we were looking to buy a new car, and had the Volt high on our list, the retired the product line.
kevin_nisbet•29 minutes ago
Not for cars, but Edison Motors in Canada seems to be going this route right now for their heavy duty trucks and heavy-duty pickup truck conversions.

Disclosure: I have a small investment in them.

obmelvin•23 minutes ago
You may be interested to read / watch videos of Audi's RS Q e-tron they raced in the Dakar Rally and even won with this type of powertrain - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Audi_RS_Q_e-tron
33MHz-i486•24 minutes ago
Ford and Ram are both doing this with their next generation electric pickups. Range and towing on pure electric was deemed too compromised.

https://www.motortrend.com/features/what-is-an-erev-extended...

fnord77•4 minutes ago
[delayed]
Jimpulse•24 minutes ago
Already a big push with this. They call them EREV now, extended range electric vehicles.
geokon•38 minutes ago
Theoretically couldn't you take an electric car and put an off-the-shelf generator in your frunk and wire it up to charge the battery as you drive?
janzer•44 minutes ago
Just a note: the Technology Connections video above goes over why this doesn't work well for cars (but does for train locomotives).
serf•about 1 hour ago
bmw I3s were this type of hybrid as far as I remember.

the ICE extender was an option.

jasonwatkinspdx•about 1 hour ago
Yup, my friends had one and loved it despite the... unique styling.

They live in the Puget Sound area, and both work at the same place. It worked out to where they could do their commute, and ordinary errands entirely on battery, and only needed the range extender if they were going into downtown Seattle or on a road trip or such.

seemaze•29 minutes ago
Isn’t that how diesel trains operate?
cyberax•about 1 hour ago
There were several of them: the first and second generations of Chevy Volt, Fisker Karma, BMW i3, and a couple of Chinese brands.

They're less efficient than parallel hybrids at high speeds (on a freeway). And you also need a fairly sizeable engine to keep up with the consumption at freeway speed, so at this point you might as well just throw in a planetary gearbox.

fnord77•5 minutes ago
[delayed]
instagib•about 2 hours ago
Hopefully it’s better than the second gen. Gas engine front only puts power to one wheel and electric rear only puts power to one wheel while the other two sit idle. Bad state for a mild 4x4 unless you keep it on pavement.