Back to News
Advertisement
Advertisement

⚡ Community Insights

Discussion Sentiment

100% Positive

Analyzed from 232 words in the discussion.

Trending Topics

#making#unions#social#remove#artisanal#knowledge#capital#industry#workers#adding

Discussion (7 Comments)Read Original on HackerNews

randycupertinoabout 5 hours ago
NY Mag looooves these status-anxiety, class warfare social commentary "what's in and what's out" style articles. It's their favorite genre and catnip to their social-climbing Yuppie core reader audience.
dorukttabout 4 hours ago
This is one of the main reasons behind all of the technological inventions applied to labour and production: to homogenize the work, remove artisanal knowledge from the worker and add it to the organic capital of industry and last but not least remove the bargaining power of the workers.
Nasrudith5 minutes ago
That is the stupidest thing I have heard all year - and that has quite a bit of competition. Because nobody is going to be grateful for you de-homogenizing work and adding requirements of artisanal knowledge, and removing capital from industry to a productive task. Because all of that translates to adding needless toil to the task, reducing productivity and making everyone poorer!

It utterly antithetical to the practice of engineering, productivity, making sense or making things better.

Get out of here and go worship Dis someplace else.

wazooxabout 2 hours ago
Yup. Good ol' Karl Marx called this process proletarianisation.
hn_user82179about 5 hours ago
atoavabout 5 hours ago
I wonder whether this is what gets tech workers to finally see the reason for unions to exist?
thedevilslawyerabout 4 hours ago
This will not work until unions deal with the reality of globalization, and push to form a worldwide union, which ensures compensation has no more than 2x difference based on one's country. This is the multiplier where people will not want to transfer work for cost vs skill level.

This is unpalatable to HCOL engineers, because their pay will significantly compress in this union to support the growth of compensation of similarly skilled LCOL regions/countries.

QED: Unions will not happen.