Back to News
Advertisement
Advertisement

⚡ Community Insights

Discussion Sentiment

0% Positive

Analyzed from 282 words in the discussion.

Trending Topics

#golf#paraquat#age#course#living#groundwater#courses#may#probably#herbicides

Discussion (7 Comments)Read Original on HackerNews

randycupertinoabout 16 hours ago
ticulatedsplineabout 15 hours ago
fun stuff. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paraquat

> China also banned the domestic use of Paraquat in 2017;

> Paraquat is widely used as a suicide agent in developing countries because it is widely available at low cost. Further, the toxic dose is low (10 mL or 2 teaspoons is enough to kill).

Someday (assuming humanity makes it that long) people will look back on this era the way we look back on the Romans and their lead pipes.

sbaygabout 15 hours ago
The link between Parkinson’s and herbicides is known, but I’m not so convinced it’s an issue of groundwater contamination. There are confounds in the location of both people and golf courses that are not controlled for by urban/rural/age/income/race. For example people may live near golf courses because they like to play golf. Golf courses could be located in areas where there is more agriculture, even with the urban/rural control in the model.
adjejmxbdjdnabout 6 hours ago
If you live next to a golf course you are probably living in a suburban house in the middle of nowhere and not going anywhere through the day.

Your mental stimulation once you age and aren’t able to drive much is probably at a bare minimum.

There may be similar correlations between the kind of lives people living near a golf course may have led.

altairprimeabout 1 hour ago
This is a plausible hypothesis in general, but doesn’t weaken the argument of pesticide toxicity supported by this multiplier:

> individuals living in water service areas with a golf course in vulnerable groundwater regions had 82% greater odds of developing PD compared with those in nonvulnerable groundwater regions

legitsterabout 15 hours ago
I know they probably controlled for age. But I think the correlation of age/retirement, Parkinsons, and living next to a golf course are so closely linked together that even small changes differences in cohorts are going to have extremely different outcomes.
metalmanabout 2 hours ago
it's the ploink sound causing it

which is fair, as any other cause would show up more significantly in other populations, :owner operator grounds keepers, farmers, etc. data is scued somehow.

edit: cross corelate with prevailing winds to eliminate "sprays"