Back to News
Advertisement
Advertisement

⚡ Community Insights

Discussion Sentiment

67% Positive

Analyzed from 2594 words in the discussion.

Trending Topics

#kobo#device#more#read#apps#run#kindle#don#app#books

Discussion (89 Comments)Read Original on HackerNews

the-grumpabout 2 hours ago
For the unaware, there is an existing solution that integrates with Kobo's native software (Nickel).

It has been maintained for years, and it supports every Kobo AFAIK.

It's called NickelMenu, and it's great. I'm in the Kobo ecosystem because of NickelMenu and Plato.

One note if you're thinking about getting a kobo due its relative openness: consider getting a two-core device. I did not do my homework and got a Clara BW because I don't want the color display. Later I found out that color is the only one with the two-core CPU.

thepoetabout 1 hour ago
Hey, author here. NickelMenu is terrific and Cobalt uses it to show the menu item in the default Kobo menu. It's just that Cobalt and NickelMenu are not the same in terms of project goals.

I created this as I could not find anything existing that gives the capabilities I wanted. I read several things downloaded over web apart from books on my Mac and phone, which I would prefer to do on an eInk display. Search papers on arxiv and read them offline later, Substack, even spending a lot of time on chess puzzles, monitor my Claude/Codex remotely, generate explainer audiobooks and listen to them on my bluetooth speaker etc.

The longer battery and the display makes some use cases really shine and I wanted to create apps for my own Kobo and potentially helpful for others as well.

the-grumpabout 1 hour ago
I admire and support your effort, but the title makes it sound like you couldn't run apps in the past.

Nickelmenu deserves a mention in the opening paragraph and a differentiation of what this new piece of software brings to the table.

thepoet8 minutes ago
Thank you for the kind words. I will add a page to the project explaining the differentiation.

NickelMenu is a mature project and perfect at what it does, we just have different goals. NickelMenu is designed to extend Kobo's stock interface. Cobalt is designed to be an app platform like Android has for example. I wanted app creators to just write their app logic and not build things like a UI toolkit for their apps, app lifecycle and rendering support (framebuffer drawing, partial eInk refreshes, touch input handling etc.), bluetooth handling, sensor and more. Anything launched through NickelMenu like KOReader or Plato have to implement these on their own.

AFAIK NickelMenu command actions spawn arbitrary shell cmds that inherit root from Nickel, we avoid it by running apps as separate unprivileged processes with declared capabilities like network, storage, audio, fronlight etc.

I also wanted to provide ability to quickly build apps with the SDK and our simulator to test apps on before putting it on the real device, an app store to get new apps over the WiFi after the initial USB install.

This was more oriented on making my life easier, say I have an app idea that I want on my Kobo tomorrow and how quickly can I bring it live on the device. The 'you can run apps' I wrote was meant to signify anyone can now create apps using the SDK without bothering about the device specific bits and publish them and install it via Cobalt's app store. I hope this clarifies things.

ololobus41 minutes ago
I haven’t had a chance to compare side by side, but people say that if you primarily read books/prose, the BW version is better because the screen is more crisp compared to the color version, which is still a bit blurry when you read books. That’s why I ordered BW. Did anyone compare these two side by side in real life for simple text?
johnhamlin33 minutes ago
It is maddeningly impossible to get an ereader with all three of these features: b&w screen for maximum crispness; physical buttons for reliable page turns; modern processor for speed.
pepperoni_pizza12 minutes ago
Yes. I had color Kobo, left it in the airport lounge, and bought BW one as a replacement. It is much better.
dotancohen37 minutes ago
I use a bw Boox device, a colleague has the colour version of the same device. The colour version does not show text more blurry, rather, the contrast is significantly lower. I personally prefer the bw device.
awakeasleepabout 2 hours ago
but also note that a color e-reader will have significantly worse contrast than a black and white model, which negates the usefulness of the device to people like me.
hamdingersabout 2 hours ago
What does the two-core CPU get you? I'm very satisfied with my BW with KOReader, haven't noticed any shortcomings but I only read books on it.
the-grumpabout 2 hours ago
I encounter freezes mostly when I enable Bluetooth/wifi. Haven't tried on a multi-core kobo but I imagine the UI thread can keep running there.

When reading, agree on it being more than sufficient.

My recommendation is partially because the price can be identical when they have a sale. That was the case when I got a BW--it was the same price as the color.

I should also mention I run quite a few things on my kobo: boringtun to connect to my home network, a fetcher to sync my books and feeds, Plato and its article fetcher whenever I update my Wallabag articles. I'm beyond pleased with my reader experience. The extra processing power would just be icing on the cake.

hamdingersabout 2 hours ago
Ah yeah, mine takes a while to connect to wifi too. I assumed that was just how it was, luckily I do it rarely.

I got the BW over the Color only because I had read the color screen wasn't as sharp, though I've never compared them side by side.

charles_fabout 2 hours ago
I do like my BW kobo, but it's on the slow side, even just when switching pages on the stock app ; and that's annoying. Sometimes because it's stuck it doesn't register the page change, and then it will highlight text instead. That's breaking the reading flow and I really hate that.
podgietaruabout 2 hours ago
Also NickelHook, which adds the native hooks into the Nickel application. I used it for intercepting http calls previously
jihadjihadabout 1 hour ago
Is it bad that I was disappointed after reading this, hoping for a library that handles callbacks, called NickelBack?
post-itabout 2 hours ago
I also have the Clara BW and haven't done any modding on it but it's been on my todo list. Would you be willing to briefly describe issues you've run into with it?
the-grumpabout 2 hours ago
0 issues using nickelmenu out of the box.

I recommend enabling ssh (native kobo feature) so it's easier to modify the config without needing to plug in, though obviously this is optional.

If you connect over SSH, I would recommend not touching system files. The new kobos don't have a removable SD card so if you corrupt the system files and it can't boot, you need to either do some PCB surgery or get a new mainboard.

jjkaczor25 minutes ago
Apparently the "Sage" (which is what I have currently) has a quad-core, but Kobo discontinued it. Sigh, too bad - this was my favourite to-date (needs a power-cover though...).
trencedampabout 2 hours ago
Are there any writing apps? Any way to connect a Bluetooth keyboard? (Or USB)
the-grumpabout 2 hours ago
KOReader probably lets you edit text files but I only use my kobo to read. Have not tried connecting any external devices.
bragr20 minutes ago
If someone made a Libby client for this, it would essentially be perfect for my uses.
yoavmabout 1 hour ago
FWIW, some Kobos can run PostmarketOS. I built this UI for my Clara - https://www.github.com/bjesus/air . It runs Firefox, Syncthing, KOReader, and basically anything else you can run on Linux.
wbxp99about 2 hours ago
>These are photographs of the device, not simulator captures

Thanks for the clarification Claude

m463about 1 hour ago
is claude the new sherlock?
danilocesar26 minutes ago
"confubabulating.... You're definetely right"
rgloverabout 3 hours ago
Wow. This is rad, well done. I've been trying to find an alt OS for my Clara Colour and this looks great. Being able to author apps means I can finally add a way to review my highlights/quotes and search them with ease.

Edit: damn, just saw the BW note. It looks like the Clara Colour would be blocked by Cobalt...

the-grumpabout 2 hours ago
You can already do that. Look into NickelMenu.
mkageniusabout 3 hours ago
I see a recent merge for Elips 2E support, hopefully color gets tested soon
Artgorabout 2 hours ago
Isn't the whole point of Kindle (or other ebook readers) being able to read books without distractions?
paxysabout 1 hour ago
No, the whole point is the e-ink screen. Kindle has had a web browser since the very first version, and people have managed to read books on it just fine without distractions.
AdmiralAsshatabout 2 hours ago
There's a contingent of enthusiasts who, once they find out a device runs Linux or can run Linux, seems determined to expose a terminal on it. I don't know why someone needs to SSH into their toaster, but damned if they're not gonna do it, just because they can.

Me personally, I just want a reliable toaster.

RattlesnakeJakeabout 2 hours ago
I always assume it's more for the challenge and accomplishment than anything practical. The results are always neat, but rarely anything you'd actually use for general-purpose computing.
jauntywundrkindabout 1 hour ago
This isn't Normie News! I think you are on the wrong site!

The street finds its own use for things is the excitement that we don't know what is possible, and that we ought be free to try. The amazing suite of software here sure looks like self evident proof about how exciting it is when we can go further, to me. I love the LLM prompt sidekick; super neat as an ambient display.

It's really sad how HN is so vocally anti-hacker, is so conservative, shows up so regularly to declare alliance to anti-possibility, to anti-features. For some people, they don't only fail to be interested, they are expressly anti interested, the only thing they want is for everyone else to have to live as constrained and unexplorarive and unthoughtful as they are. I don't get it. Conservatism is a wicked disease, imo.

MYEUHDabout 1 hour ago
Obviously you ssh into your toaster so you can host a website on it, or run DOOM
MathMonkeyManabout 1 hour ago
I went through a whole design phase with ChatGPT on the idea of using an old Kobo as a low-distraction TV remote for my dad. The idea is that it would interface with a computer media server thing, be more legible than a traditional remote, and not be an app on his phone that would immediately send him into his phone.

Ended up being more involved than the benefit it would bring, especially considering that these media server programs know how to interface with the traditional remote over HDMI (if you have the right graphics card or a dongle) and show the selection UI on screen like a smart TV.

Anyway, my response is "you don't necessarily have to complicate your e-reader, instead you have the option of making it not an e-reader."

BeetleBabout 1 hour ago
Even if you want it for just books, there are benefits to installing things like KOReader (way better ebook reader than the default). This allows you to sync with Calibre, etc.

Years ago, it was practically a hobby of mine to go to my local Goodwill, and find an extremely cheap old used Kobo and find someone to donate it to. Now I'm thinking of getting old Kobos just for the eink display so I can run simple apps on it - while continuing to use my regular Kobo as an ereader.

dotancohen6 minutes ago
Why use a Kobo for that? Nook and Boox devices run Android - I've run Ankidroid on both those devices.
NewJazzabout 2 hours ago
Some people came for the compact package containing an eink screen, a moderately powered application board, and a reasonable amount of battery and storage. For some, it may be the perfect thin client.
ashu1461about 2 hours ago
In my personal experience, this can help in case the books are little technical and you have to switch to my laptop/mobile to get more information about the topic, which ends up consuming more time it should.
unethical_banabout 2 hours ago
That's what I want from my e-reader device too. Yet being able to turn a $140 e-ink tablet into a general purpose tool is really neat.
conqrrabout 2 hours ago
Very cool and definitely useful. I'm not the audience but I'll say: I like my ereader to just have books that sync. That is all. It's my library room and peace time, the last thing I need is Claude to distract me.
QwenGlazer9000about 2 hours ago
For most of the use cases I would need an app for, koreader's plugin system works just fine for it. You'd be surprised the gems you can find for koreader.
VariousProgramsabout 1 hour ago
I am enjoying the recently trendy Xteink e-readers that can't do anything but read books. An app store and the internet would just make an e-reader feel like a "worse phone" to me.
5G_activatedabout 1 hour ago
I find LLM copywriting revolting, especially Claude's and it is pretty obvious that it is Claude, and even though I might find the software interesting since I own a Clara 2E, it puts such a sour taste in my mouth that I don't want to touch this thing with a 10 foot pole.

If your software is mostly written by the slop machine, fine. I don't have to be upset about it unless I think about contributing and then notice the uncanny nature of the source code. But a website and a README is directly user facing and it is a major disservice, and in my opinion, lack of respect, to generate your website copy with an LLM.

mortenjorck37 minutes ago
My reaction was perhaps not as strongly felt as yours, but I agree that it discourages me from reading further when it's obvious I'm reading slop rather than something a human considered.

"These are photographs of the device, not simulator captures" is the kind of total throwaway verbiage that a human would never even pause to consider writing because it "clarifies" something that in the totality of context is beyond obvious. It makes the writing more fatiguing to read, and creates a terrible first impression for a project.

zuzululuabout 1 hour ago
i could care less as long as it works and does what it describes

much prefer ai assisted development than someone who does it by hand, prone to errors and lacking in features.

hk__212 minutes ago
> much prefer ai assisted development than someone who does it by hand, prone to errors and lacking in features.

You prefer AI-assisted development with errors and lacking features rather than something done by hand with errors and lacking features?

pmkaryabout 3 hours ago
As a Kindle owner; I'm very jealous.
SpecialistKabout 2 hours ago
You can do a lot of the same things with a jailbroken Kindle and KindleForge.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l4ZliC82RtA

kioleanuabout 1 hour ago
You can jailbreak your kindle and get similar functionality through KOReader plugins https://omer-faruq.github.io/appstore.koplugin/
MathMonkeyManabout 1 hour ago
Give Rakuten your money!
baal80spamabout 3 hours ago
I'm not. I want my Kindle to do ONE job well, not turn into another multi-purpose device.
speak_plainlyabout 3 hours ago
I too would like my Kindle to do one single thing well. Sadly, we seem to be waiting for that future to arrive.
RankingMemberabout 2 hours ago
I remember when my PaperWhite glitched while I was attempting to jailbreak it and got stuck with the screen inverted. It was great! I can't believe I have to jailbreak a reader to get that simple functionality for better in-the-dark reading. (epilogue: I let it run out of battery and the inversion was gone upon boot)
bigyabaiabout 2 hours ago
Yeah, I was going to say. I only installed KOReader because my Kindle Touch has lackluster ereader functionality.
RattlesnakeJakeabout 2 hours ago
I still miss the UI on my old Kindle Keyboard, which only showed the book list without an attempt at curation/upselling.

I can simulate it by staying on the "Library" tab, but it tends to forget halfway frequently.

utopiahabout 3 hours ago
It is totally different to be able to do something versus actually doing it.

It is not because you can install and run apps that you have to.

NewJazzabout 2 hours ago
That's what's great about open hardware. You still have the ability to do that. Even if the original vendor of the device tries to decide differently.
pmkaryabout 1 hour ago
I'm like yours, But there are things that makes me angry. I cannot for example read Farsi books. I cannot put a new e-pub into my kindle and I have to send it over the web; there are many things like these. And so I just want to have a nicer reader that I myself control.
poopbutt16about 1 hour ago
So... don't use it, idk?
adezxcabout 3 hours ago
the one job that it does well is show you ads lmao (in case you haven't jailbreaked your Kindle yet)
kelvinjps10about 2 hours ago
Not to defend amazon but you can remove the ads by paying to remove them, they sell one model ad supported and another that doesn't have ads if you buy the ads supported you can remove it later.
toomuchtodoabout 2 hours ago
Your Kindle is an appliance you have little control over, the Kobo in this scope is a multitool. More choice is better than less choice as it relates to device ownership and control, imho.

https://www.fulu.org/

HN Search: enshittification - https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=false&qu...

rjrjrjrjabout 1 hour ago
Along with choice comes complexity. More things to break, security problems, distractions, etc. Purpose-built devices like the Kindle and Switch do one thing well; this looks like it does a lot more things but mostly poorly.

Everyone already has at least one multitool, the smartphone. Most also have a tablet and/or a laptop. While this project looks like a cool hack, I don't see much practical use for another multitool with a weak CPU, laggy screen, and poor input.

Advertisement
far_focusabout 2 hours ago
So cool. I have this exact model. Might try to build something
podgietaruabout 2 hours ago
Previously I built something using NickelHook

https://github.com/Podginator/KoboOmnivoreConverter

It took a lot of messing around trying to figure out how nickel fit together. This is much more … impressive.

jhackabout 2 hours ago
This is incredible and super useful. More reasons to use my e-reader around the house instead of my phone.
khalicabout 1 hour ago
Very cool project, will try to make it run on my device
erelongabout 2 hours ago
Noting again that postmarketos exists and works on some kobos (and potentially could be ported to more?)
GlenTheMachineabout 2 hours ago
I vote for Zotero integration!
ee334y5rthsrthabout 1 hour ago
I need OTP for loging to ssh and meshtastic
luciana1uabout 1 hour ago
an e-reader running apps feels like putting a treadmill in a library. next thing you know it's nagging you with a notification badge for 'you haven't read in 3 days'.
juleiie42 minutes ago
I don't know for who this is honestly

I mean I got a laptop, e ink laptop would be cool but this certainly isn't it and who needs a book with Claude code agent? You either read or you do what exactly with that linux pc on a book hardcover? Just grab your laptop like a normal civilized person

dylandoddsabout 2 hours ago
Just bought a kobo bw after reading this article
jasongiabout 3 hours ago
Amazing. Hopefully Kobo don't ruin this by locking it down.
Advertisement
sa-codeabout 3 hours ago
Would this also work on a Tolino?
oynqrabout 2 hours ago
The Tolino Shine 5 is the same hardware. You can even install the kobo firmware.
BoingBoomTschakabout 2 hours ago
Vibecoded, from what I see in the git log.
code-bloodedabout 2 hours ago
I think so too. I wish all projects had a tag with amount of AI usage.

It's not that vibe coding is bad on its own, but it makes me worried about project's future (ease come, easy go).

NewJazzabout 1 hour ago
This wasn't a flag?

Store-only by design: installing it proves delivery of an app the USB package never contained.

gadrevabout 2 hours ago
Yes. Also from looking for device compatibility:

> Tested on one device: the Kobo Clara BW (N365, device code 391), firmware 4.45.23697. Every device write is gated on an exact match of framebuffer identity, geometry, device code, serial model prefix, firmware version and kernel release, so a different reader is refused rather than guessed at.

I can't stop reading "gated" on LLM output lately.

Anyways, I wish this worked on my Libra :<

fluidcruftabout 2 hours ago
Was it the "AI Command Center" app that gave it away? That could actually be pretty cool. Read a book on the deck with the vibemill running in the background.
Cyph0nabout 2 hours ago
Even the homepage copy is LLM output. Not necessarily a bad thing, but something to point out.

> Charge a Kobo Clara BW (N365) and connect it over USB. Other models are refused, not guessed at.

ashu1461about 2 hours ago
Isn't everything vibecoded ?
bellowsgulchabout 2 hours ago
poob has it for you
teddyh37 minutes ago
The only “Kobo” I know of is a game which was popular around 1993, a remake for X11/Unix of the old 1981 Bosconian arcade game. A recent active fork can still be installed on modern systems as “Kobo Deluxe”.
zuzululuabout 1 hour ago
now if something like this released for amazon kindle i would dust it off and start actually using the device again