RU version is available. Content is displayed in original English for accuracy.
Advertisement
Advertisement
⚡ Community Insights
Discussion Sentiment
80% Positive
Analyzed from 1084 words in the discussion.
Trending Topics
#more#parents#life#embryos#story#genetic#children#through#lives#llm

Discussion (28 Comments)Read Original on HackerNews
Is this more than a harness built on top of a SOTA commercial LLM?
We're talking about a deep human experience here. I don't know about HN as a whole but I personally come out of this much more touched about the human side of the story and how someone's life events can tremendously change their paths and goals than the LLM itself.
Most Down Syndrome people have happy lives, some can even leave alone and have an independent daily live.
Life expectancy is up to 60 years.
Yet in Iceland „Democratization“ of genetic diagnosis lead to basically 0% Down Syndrome kids.
Where does this stop? What with someone of a genetic indication of aggressive cancer- life expectancy 55? Abort?
The same (detectable) genetic mutation leads to vastly different lives.
As for trisomy-21, if we wish to increase the rates in the future we can stop performing pre-implantation testing and the MSAFP and nuchal translucency and so on. After all, even if we abort all embryos that carry the markers today, new such embryos will be formed in the future since it comes from non-disjunction so selection pressure once removed will allow it to return.
My friend from elementary school has had a Down kid at 19. She takes it well, but managing a grown-up man five times as strong as her (she is petite) when he decides to do something like "take his bicycle and ride on a busy highway" is exhausting.
This is why most people abort Down fetuses.
As an aside, I have not found SF to be anti-natal but that's because of the community we've formed. Of our friends in SF, almost all are trying for children or have them. Our shared Slack group is full of happy news. Inevitably, many of us must move elsewhere in order to allow them some freedom[2] and good education[3]. So there's a bit of a dead-sea effect, true, but even within that sea there are pockets of community one can find.
0: https://wiki.roshangeorge.dev/w/IVF but also see https://viz.roshangeorge.dev/roshan-genvue/ to see an old set of results and download my VCF here https://my.pgp-hms.org/profile/hu81A8CC and put it through a modern (but not too modern LLM) to get some fun results if you want a starter data set to peek through. Opus can get you far.
1: Fable as expected yields:
2: Within the last year 2 children have been killed in our neighbourhood by drivers, and parents in the US already compensate by cutting child freedom significantly3: Since school system design is determined by both parents and non-parents, it is a vehicle of expression of non-education-related action by the latter, and in a city where they dominate the former, the effects are typical
Peering through the NICU window & wondering if my child would survive was one of the most traumatizing moments of my life. Rooting for your work.
No matter how short his life, or how much his suffering, Owen did get to experience being held by parents who loved him.
Godspeed.
oh boy
> It was clear that something about my approach was interesting.
But no approach. Not even a hint.
I do hope it pans out. I do understand it must be a trade secret in order for you to have a business, but I'm still a little underwhelmed.
If they can save more lives without harming other lives I would gladly take it during the analysis. Even saving 1% more lives is an amazing achievement!
Internet reply: this is extremely disturbing
Its a sad story. I wish them well, I hope this is one of those scenarios that AI works exactly as desired.