No AI Co-Authors. A Manifesto

Discussion (9 Comments)Read Original on HackerNews

wongarsu•about 2 hours ago

The manifesto is somehow devoid of coherent arguments. You are still personally listed as the author of your commits, adding a co-author is not a mechanism for moving all accountability to that co-author. That's not what a co-author is.

I suspect the author of the website forgot to include in their prompt why they actually dislike AI Co-Author attributions. Or maybe they just have really bad colleagues

And that's while there are plenty of good reasons not to list the AI as co-author. I stopped letting Claude include it

zethraeus•about 1 hour ago

Funny story: I made this because despite having the global no-attribution setting turned on, Claude still regularly tags itself.

I'm sure it's a context thing — but boy is it annoying.

vindin•about 2 hours ago

Broken on mobile, and clearly written by an AI co-author.

This sounds like Claude from a mile away

“It strikes the tool. It keeps the person. Matching runs on both the display name and the email, normalized — so a renamed bot or a numeric noreply address doesn’t slip through. A human is never in the blast radius.”

zethraeus•about 1 hour ago

Thanks for the mobile heads up!

The manifesto is me. The website is not — and I'd like to argue that's very non-ironic!

Here's the making of, linked at the bottom. https://no-ai-coauthors.dev/making-of.html

mrcslws•11 minutes ago

I can confirm, this is how Adam talks.

zethraeus•about 2 hours ago

AI Co-authors are impressive marketing, but deleterious to dev work.

This manifesto website includes a git commit-msg hook for your favorite hook manager, and a GitHub Action for preventing contributions containing them from landing in your project.

mrlowlevel•about 2 hours ago

Ironic this website has AI written all over it.

zethraeus•about 1 hour ago

I'm the author ('author'?), and I'll push back: it's solidly non-ironic!

Here's a link from the bottom of the page. https://no-ai-coauthors.dev/making-of.html

blinkbat•about 2 hours ago

Broken on mobile

No AI Co-Authors. A Manifesto

⚡ Community Insights

Discussion (9 Comments)Read Original on HackerNews