The Computational Theory of Mind (2015)

Discussion (8 Comments)Read Original on HackerNews

Beijinger•about 1 hour ago

Not broad enough. Better: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Calculating_Space

cyanregiment•about 1 hour ago

♥

firasd•about 1 hour ago

Doesn’t the concept of a subconscious, or inner voice, invalidate any tight analogies to Turing Machines? What logical process is putting the Fur Elise into my head (earworms etc)

I think this article is right that definitions really matter here cause one could argue “CTM is trivial, because we can describe almost any physical system as executing computations.” So we have a dual problem here—not just the difficult discussion of ‘what’s going on in minds’, but also ‘what is computation’.

cat-whisperer•about 1 hour ago

I would agree, but I recently read https://transformer-circuits.pub/2026/workspace/index.html which is quite interesting in it's own right.

What are your thoughts on this?

firasd•about 1 hour ago

Are LLMs even covered by ‘computational theory of mind’? Cause if I say “I like to bake” the LLM is only able to recognize and respond to that sentence due to the neural network making emergent connections between the tokens in the words—very different from the kind of computer programs these guys seem to have been thinking about.

BobbyTables2•about 1 hour ago

Wonder if the subconscious could simply be another LLM with a higher temperature setting…

Have long thought that creativity is little more than a finely tuned filter driven by noise…

TheOtherHobbes•44 minutes ago

Infuriatingly, computation is subjective. The experience of the inputs, the results, and the processes depends on qualia. So does logic itself.

Automating the processes doesn't change that. There's a very large number of possible processes and operations, but only a small number are perceived as valuable.

soupspaces•about 1 hour ago

https://philosophynow.org/issues/132/About_Aboutness

The Computational Theory of Mind (2015)

⚡ Community Insights

Discussion (8 Comments)Read Original on HackerNews