OpenTrafficMap

118

mmoooo99 about 4 hours ago 25 commentsRead Article on opentrafficmap.org

ZH version is available. Content is displayed in original English for accuracy.

⚡ Community Insights

Discussion Sentiment

100% Positive

Analyzed from 607 words in the discussion.

Discussion (25 Comments)Read Original on HackerNews

mlaretallack•about 3 hours ago

Found out about this today, up until now 802.11p hardware is very expensive, and so you cannot easily do anything with V2x messages like CAM or SPAT, but the fact this was done with sub £20 hardware is really interesting.

solarpunk•about 3 hours ago

Cool, but it there's no links for more info, and it doesn't seem to work in the USA at all.

uyzstvqs•20 minutes ago

The site is definitely lacking. It's half in German, half in English.

The concept is that there is this protocol called ITS-G5, which is a European profile of 802.11p. Vehicles and traffic infrastructure can transmit telemetry on 5 GHz. Other vehicles and traffic infrastructure can use it for situational awareness.

This website collects that data using local receivers and aggregates it onto a map, similar to what website like ADSB-Exchange do with ADS-B.

What is concerning is that vehicles appear to broadcast a MAC address. Does this mean that ITS-G5, 802.11p, and C-ITS could be used for persistent tracking?

moooo99•about 3 hours ago

The project was shared as part of a talk at Graz Linux Tage. You can find it here, unfortunately it is only available in German

https://media.ccc.de/v/glt26-688-c-its-mit-einem-esp32-ampel...

refulgentis•29 minutes ago

Pastebin here containing AI-generated English translation, LGTM: https://pastebin.com/fK5Atwzg

RobotToaster•about 2 hours ago

Is there a link to the hardware they mention in the description?

felixguendling•about 3 hours ago

It's based on Car2X/Vehicle2X data that's sent unencrypted and can be received with chips you can order from China.

rootusrootus•about 3 hours ago

Will be interesting to see how it fares when it does come to the US. It seems like there are some cars that already have the tech installed. But the US is allegedly more interested in the cellular version, which I am guessing is not as easy to pick up with a simple receiver?

My gut feeling is that this seems like one of those things likely to face a lot of backlash when it becomes widely known.

felixguendling•about 3 hours ago

I guess we only find out if some people order those chips and check if there is some data. From my understanding the idea is the same like maps showing air planes or ships (for ships it’s AIS). So without volunteers/pioneers who participate we won’t know. It seems like traffic lights and trams also can send data.

walrus01•about 3 hours ago

If I had a dollar for every time I've seen an American on the Internet assume that anything published in the English language must be US-centric...

bravoetch•about 3 hours ago

You still wouldn't have nearly as many dollars if you subtracted the times those people were correct in that assumption. Personally I assumed the site would be global. It doesn't have any info though, so I rely on finding out somewhere else I guess.

lucideer•about 1 hour ago

> Personally I assumed the site would be global

The only reason you would assume a site would be global is if your definition of "global" is "works in the US" & you never bother to check for support of other countries. I live in the anglosphere outside of the US & I encounter more than enough US-only web projects for that not be to a default assumption I hold.

Most sites are not global - it's very odd to assume they would be.

hamdingers•about 3 hours ago

It seems pretty weird to use all English words in the domain for a service that offers no English translations and operates in no English speaking countries.

moooo99•about 2 hours ago

The map is based on international standards and technically it does not restrict locations to German speaking countries.

The authors of this project also shared that they intend on publishing more around this project. This seems to be mostly an early demo that was intended for the live event.

walrus01•about 3 hours ago

The Germans and Danes and Swedes and Norwegians I see on the Internet developing and publishing software often have a better grasp of the English language than many born in the USA Americans.

perching_aix•about 3 hours ago

Is expecting something to work in the US the same as expecting it to be US-centric?

rootusrootus•about 3 hours ago

Conversely, if I had a penny for every time someone complained about Americans... ;-)

amazingamazing•about 3 hours ago

This is an American site to be fair. Mapbox is also an American company.

estimator7292•about 1 hour ago

OpenStreetMaps works in the US and much of the rest of the world.

It's entirely reasonable to expect that a project with an extremely similar name would also work in most of the world, which just happens to include the USA.

exegete•about 3 hours ago

I mean I don’t anyone thought this was in the US since the UI is not in English. Maybe it’s more of, this neat, wish we had it here?

poorman•about 1 hour ago

I wonder if this could be used to track location of the vehicle

embedding-shape•about 1 hour ago

Isn't that the point of the project? I'm seeing a bunch of tracked vehicles, although they all seem parked at the moment.

Does Graz not have night bus service?

xd1936•about 3 hours ago

I haven't seen a theme on OSM data look this modern and fresh before. Beautiful color palette and iconography!

stevenhubertron•about 3 hours ago

It's a Mapbox theme

Cider9986•about 3 hours ago

>WebSocket getrennt

Hug of death? Nothing loads.