Back to News
Advertisement
Advertisement

⚡ Community Insights

Discussion Sentiment

30% Positive

Analyzed from 4414 words in the discussion.

Trending Topics

#trump#https#don#more#com#kushner#things#albania#world#those

Discussion (198 Comments)Read Original on HackerNews

bkovacevabout 9 hours ago
Jared Kushner tried a similar thing in Serbia[0] and failed after a public outrage.

[0] https://www.washingtonpost.com/world/2025/12/17/serbia-trump...

rapindabout 8 hours ago
That Ivanka podcast interview about this island will go down as a masterpiece in tone-deafness. I assume there are already memes of it.
airstrikeabout 8 hours ago
My absolute favorite, for those who missed it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oBEDGJE0_yI
dieselgateabout 1 hour ago
The short segment I saw on reddit, I believe, of Ivanka talking about an island gave VERY strong AI vibes. Is this interview real and are there links? This is the first I've seen it referenced so haven't given it much thought.
port11about 5 hours ago
tl;dl We found a true paradise and want to destroy it to build a resort.
LearnYouALispabout 8 hours ago
Oh, 'highlights'?
joquarkyabout 4 hours ago
It doesn't matter how tone deaf it is, they are so wealthy they don't care.
FireBeyondabout 7 hours ago
And Trump's plan to build a skyscraper on Australia's Gold Coast was nixed a month or two ago because his partner on it bailed because of its "toxic associations".
annagio_about 9 hours ago
Half of Albania is butchered like this, beaches and green being destroyed to make resorts for the tourists to come. Go see Dermi or Vuno and then go see Borsh how clean it is, with no excavations at all or resorts being build.
whatever1about 8 hours ago
Don't forget that resorts et al typically belong to international capital, and the tourists rarely leave the premises.

So what does the local economy get out of it? A few maids salary to clean up the tourist's shit?

hammockabout 8 hours ago
> Don't forget that resorts et al typically belong to international capital. What does the local economy get out of it?

Same goes for any natural resource. Oil, precious metals, water, etc. Globalization feeds this behavior, but that’s a conversation people don’t usually want to have

Avicebronabout 7 hours ago
hisses in neolib and skitters back to the shadows but but trickle down
dominotwabout 8 hours ago
what about tax revenue ?
whatever1about 8 hours ago
Most resorts secure favorable tax deals directly from the central governments before they invest, accompanied by public announcements in the media about success of government in attracting international investments.

So no tax the locals. During the construction phase there is some legitimate economy uplift (similar to datacenters). But after that nothing.

Tangurena2about 8 hours ago
"Big money" tends to extort the same sort of tax deals that American sports stadiums get: they get huge tax breaks and while the registers at the stadium look like they're charging sales tax, that money goes directly to the stadium owners, not the government. Sometimes these deals are called "special economic zone".
hedoraabout 7 hours ago
I challenge you to find a single example anywhere on earth where redistribution of foreign tax revenue significantly improved the economic standing of the existing general population.
woodpanelabout 7 hours ago
Tax revenue, local jobs, and the possiblity for entrepreneurs to build businesses around that possibility of tourists leaving the premise.

With all that being said, I still think that overreliance on tourism is bad for a place in principle. Those places fossilize, the wealth of tourists overwhelmes local culture, it will create wrong incentives, draw in junk vendors, pick-pocketers, and AirBnB vultures making life more miserable for the locals. One can also be certain that the local hospitality operators will try to pass the least possible amount to locals by finding even cheaper employees from god knows where.

1234letshaveatwabout 7 hours ago
such a stark contrast with all the hysteria over foreign tourists avoiding the US due to Trump that was posted here a few days ago. "Oh noes Trump is destroying the tourist economy!!!" vs. "only a few maids salary to clean up the tourist's shit"
filleduchaosabout 6 hours ago
Do you unironically think that all tourism is resort tourism?
esquire_900about 8 hours ago
We happened to be in Borsh beach around a week or so ago, and that will be a tourist wreck in 2 years. Multiple working sites, 70% of the beach already claimed by beds.

Quite laid-back in May / start of June, but I do not want to be there in the high season.

icarabout 3 hours ago
All coastal zones are. Mallorca is the same, for example. Eivissa as well. Many parts of València, etc. And that's just the ones I know.
skinfaxiabout 8 hours ago
Same in Greece. Right off the coast of Albania, Corfu is seeing heavy development as well.
tweetle_beetleabout 7 hours ago
Corfu has been a mainstream holiday destination for Europeans for half a century. I don't think it's really in the same category as Albania.
adjejmxbdjdnabout 7 hours ago
I simply don’t understand how American voters are fine with being robbed blind.

Many countries have far more corrupt administrations than the current U.S. one, but even in the most degenerate ones none of them are as open about it.

And it’s not just a political thing.

Consider how the Chinese owned Smithfield’s is polluting lakes and land all over the Midwest with their highly intensive (and incredibly cruel) pig farming that is causing high cancer and mortality rates for the people living there, and yet the locals tend to support whatever Smithfield wants.

skybrianabout 7 hours ago
Americans aren’t “fine with it.” Trump’s approval ratings are very low.

https://www.reuters.com/business/energy/trump-approval-stays...

cosmicgadgetabout 5 hours ago
Which is weird because this is pretty much what they voted/abstained for. I think we have to trust the ballot box more than opinion polls.
rurpabout 3 hours ago
It's a two party system in a big complicated country. Voting for a candidate you dislike and often disagree with is the norm. People vote against opposing candidates as much as they vote for something, especially in recent years.

In the particular case of trump, the less one knows about politics and governing the more likely they are to support him. The US is full of people who don't care much about how government actually works, which is not an unreasonable position for the most part, but can get hijacked by an effective conman.

datsci_est_2015about 4 hours ago
> I think we have to trust the ballot box more than opinion polls.

I think voting trends are a pretty poor signal of voter values, but a much stronger signal of voter “alignment”, especially in first-past-the-post systems.

skybrianabout 3 hours ago
They didn't vote for a war with Iran.
2OEH8eoCRo0about 7 hours ago
philistineabout 5 hours ago
Donald Trump was re-elected because too many voters who voted against him the last two times stayed home. That they don't approve, yet did not go vote, is the textbook definition of fine with it. America does not have a wellspring of anti-Trump voters just waiting to be awakened.

America is Trump.

hedoraabout 7 hours ago
I don’t get it either. I think it is a combination of the two party system, and short attention span / tribalism.

Look at the California primaries. In every race I can name, the right wing (like funded by the same people as Trump levels of right wing) and the republican token candidate are advancing to the general election.

We have open primaries, so, in theory, there could be a corporate democrat vs. a populist/progressive democrat in the general elections.

I say “token” republicans because they are clearly sending the B team. One ran on “too many dogs get to vote” and another (who advanced) on a transphobic platform.

Typical breakdowns of California primaries in Silicon Valley, translated to European norms: 5% left, 15-25% center left, 30-35 moderate to hard right, 35-40 right wing nationalist.

In the general, the first three categories will collapse, and the moderate to hard right democrat that gets elected will claim they have a mandate from the voters.

Edit: The narrative dominating the news cycle is Trump’s claim the elections are rigged because the results were so far to the left. I guess he wants two republicans facing off in every general election race, despite the state being overwhelmingly blue.

Also, on ballot initiatives, the state overwhelmingly votes left, not moderate right, so, when presented with an actual policy decision, they vote completely differently than they do when given a choice of candidates.

stevenwooabout 4 hours ago
There’s one bright spot, the Los Angeles mayoral race eliminated the MAGA candidate so it’s a corporate Dem versus more left Dem.
superloikaabout 7 hours ago
It's because the massess are cattle themselves.
swed420about 7 hours ago
'The Century of the Self' really drives this point.

https://thoughtmaybe.com/the-century-of-the-self

Then corporate social media took things to the next level.

unharmed474about 7 hours ago
My theory is that the US isn’t really a democratic society anymore. Immigration has changed the fabric of the country so much that a lot of newer Americans still haven’t fully assimilated into American culture yet.
yacinabout 7 hours ago
Are you suggesting that immigrants are to blame for electing the current administration that's robbing them blind?
hedoraabout 7 hours ago
Most people in my social circles that do not feel the US is in an existential crisis are first generation immigrants.

They see the checks and balances that we used to have, and assumed those structures would constrain the administration to mostly tow the line.

On the one hand, it’s true they came from places with weaker institutions. On the other hand, they’re used to leaders that face real threats of coup, asset seizure, assassination, etc. The current US administration has publicly stated it is permanently above the law, and it has also dismantled most checks and balances.

cosmicgadgetabout 5 hours ago
Weird to equate "American culture" and being able to understand democracy.
totetsuabout 9 hours ago
I wonder how many more things like this are happening under the radar around the world
billforabout 8 hours ago
The article says: "If it was not Jared, they would not give a shit about what is happening in Albania," Rama said."
cosmicgadgetabout 5 hours ago
Jared or some of the other White House insiders trying to offshore their recent financial gains.
FireBeyondabout 6 hours ago
Oh, this Rama?

> Rama, a long-time friend of the Trump and Kushner families

> The protests, which civil society and international media have called the Flamingo Revolution, have grown well past their environmental starting point into a challenge to Rama himself

(because of accusations he's bending regulations for Kushner that exist for other companies).

> On 30 December 2024, a Strategic Investment Committee chaired by Rama granted strategic investor status to Atlantic Incubation Partners, a firm affiliated with Kushner's Affinity Partners ... Reuters, which saw the written decision, reported .... the terms include no tax during the construction phase while the Albanian state underwrites the water, electricity and sewage infrastructure.

Yeah, forgive me if I don't exactly see his opinion as unbiased.

ToucanLoucanabout 8 hours ago
Every time you hear about some corpo or another getting to "play a role in the development of $nation" it's pretty much always going to be some kind of bullshit that will employ a lot of locals for shit wages to provide a product or service to residents of the Global North.

There are exceptions of course but the vast, vast, vast majority are tourist trapping and wealth extraction.

1over137about 9 hours ago
This is hardly under the radar, it’s all over the news.
frereubuabout 9 hours ago
They mean an attempt like this, but one that they manage to keep quiet and out of the press.
pavel_lishinabout 9 hours ago
I wonder, if I asked the next dozen people I meet, whether they would have any idea about this.
KPGv2about 8 hours ago
The only people this is relevant to are Albanians. I don't expect an Albanian to know about data centers being built in Texas. Hell, I don't expect Michiganders to know about them.
rnxrxabout 7 hours ago
Maybe it’s naive, but there’s something incredibly hopeful that there are folks not only protesting this kind of corruption, but also that there’s a government actually responding to the voice of the people. That the EU’s own legal frameworks might positively (if indirectly) affect things is even better.
toasty228about 8 hours ago
The rich are getting too openly greedy and complacent again, they're slowly forgetting about history, can't wait to see how it pans out in the next decades.

https://www.prosperosisle.org/spip.php?article1196

renegade-otterabout 8 hours ago
Which is ironic because Rae Kushner - his grandmother - is a legend. She has gone through some things.

Now her grandson is wrecking Europe.

https://www.npr.org/2018/05/04/560224531/trump-stories-kushn...

agnosticmantisabout 8 hours ago
Would you elaborate why she's considered a legend?

She was certainly a victim and a refugee, of which we have many today, most being denied admission to the US. Are those all legends too?

renegade-otterabout 4 hours ago
She was in Jewish underground resistance after she escaped the ghetto, and that movement was responsible for saving a lot of lives. Sure, not a shockingly unique story in WWII, but she did better than these upward fail sons.
justin66about 8 hours ago
Never heard of her. His father, the tax evading felon recently pardoned by Trump, is rather more well known I would think. (But hardly a legend)
woodpanelabout 7 hours ago
well a legend he is, if we are to believe what former New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie said about what the pardon was for: "one of the most loathsome, disgusting crimes" he ever prosecuted as U.S. attorney.
lifestyleguruabout 8 hours ago
Present America is real estate developers all the way down.
Ccecilabout 8 hours ago
Real estate, Crypto and AI make up the 3 legged stool of US investment (from my perspective).

In my area which is over 1/3 retired people this is where the majority of their investments seem to lie. Those who are simply relying on 401k or other investments are also at risk due to the lack of diversification. Since their investments are tied to those 3 things.

If any of the legs of the stool go out...the whole thing goes down.

drstewartabout 8 hours ago
Wait till you see the housing market in other Anglo countries.
nulloremptyabout 8 hours ago
All the great art should teach us that we can't take riches to the grave, it's too bad that this is being forgotten.

Then again, may be they already figured out how to make their lives meaningfully longer. I often think what drives 80 year old Bidens and Trumps to live the stressful POTUS life.

And I can think of only one incentive. Weird thoughts, but otherwise the dots just don't connect.

avgDevabout 7 hours ago
Different people are driven by different things. Some people genuinely want to serve their nation and being a president is a huge honor to the family. You become part of history.

Others may be serving their own interests as it gives them access to all information.

Others may just want the power.

sys_64738about 8 hours ago
I thought Albania still had concrete bunkers around the coast to keep unwanted invaders OUT.
Brendinoooabout 7 hours ago
What is this news source? I've never heard of it before and there are no names associated with it on their site. Two of their social media links are broken. Their YouTube channel was only active for like a year, 4-5 years ago. It all feels strange.
unharmed474about 7 hours ago
The news is everywhere, I don’t know why they picked this source.

https://www.nbcnews.com/world/europe/kushner-luxury-resort-p...

Just google Albania Flamingo revolution.

pjc50about 9 hours ago
partial225about 9 hours ago
This led to the greatest trolling of an individual ever when they deliberately stuck a windfarm directly off the coast of his new golf course. He's spent a couple of decades spending countless millions in losing a bunch of court cases, and of course, to this day, constantly moans to anyone who will list about "windmills".

As far as trolling goes, it's one of the greatest achievements in the history of mankind.

cosmicgadgetabout 3 hours ago
On par with publicly embarrassing someone's birtherism at the White House Correspondents' Dinner.

That blowback though.

fooblasterabout 9 hours ago
unfortunately this trolling has caused trump to try to halt all large offshore wind projects in the United States in federal land grants. it's terrible.
thefzabout 9 hours ago
Yep absolutely this and not at all big oil money/interest.
amiga386about 9 hours ago
For the gory details, see

1. Donald Trump's Ego Trip - lessons for the new Scotland (2011) https://andywightman.scot/docs/trumpreport_v1a.pdf

2. You've Been Trumped (2011) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vr6efmndvps

thih9about 8 hours ago
Wow! I especially like this:

> Scottish people formed a Tripping Up Trump Campaign to make it more difficult to transfer the title to the land, and hundreds of people bought small interests in Forbes' property and became co-owners.

Continued in another article[1]:

> When it emerged at the end of January 2011 that Queen guitarist Brian May had agreed to the use of the band's song "Bohemian Rhapsody" in a film highlighting the plight of the families, Trump appeared to deny in a media statement that there had ever been an eviction threat, declaring "we have no interest in compulsory purchase and have never applied for it."

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trump_International_Golf_Links...

adf-aslkabout 9 hours ago
This island was a Russian naval base in the cold war with hundreds of underground nuclear bunkers.

Kushner apparently wants to build a billionaire resort with the protections required to insulate billionaires from their actions. Maybe UAE is too dangerous now.

Here is another article. Try not to be put off by the Rothchild connections, they are mostly irrelevant and based on Kushner's own statements:

https://tomselliott.substack.com/p/what-is-jared-kushner-act...

water-data-dudeabout 9 hours ago
If things ever get bad enough that the wealthy need underground nuclear bunkers, the underground nuclear bunkers aren't going to be enough to protect them. The ordinary people who did the electrical, plumbing, security, etc. know where you are, and no level of security will protect you from an angry mob with nothing to lose.
graphimeabout 9 hours ago
> The ordinary people who did the electrical, plumbing, security, etc. know where you are, and no level of security will protect you from an angry mob with nothing to lose.

Governments around the world already keep many locations/facilities secret and hidden from the public.

They will simply arrest you, or worse, just kill you.

What’s your solution to that?

flohofwoeabout 8 hours ago
> Governments around the world already keep many locations/facilities secret and hidden from the public.

Those cold war bunkers only had one purpose: to keep high ranking government and military peeps alive just long enough (up to 2 weeks or so) to make sure that mutual destruction is actually 'assured'. They were not meant as some sort of cradle of a new civilization or as a safe haven to survive a nuclear war (because there would be no place to return to anyway).

water-data-dudeabout 4 hours ago
I'm talking about the wealthy building private end of the world bunkers
everyoneabout 8 hours ago
Have you thought this through fully? In that case who'se supposed to be doing the arresting and killing? -- more ordinary people.

Look at what happened to Ceaușescu for example. He went from being confident in his rule to dead 24 hours later.

hedoraabout 7 hours ago
I once saw a news article with interviews of anonymous bunker tenders; essentially, there is a small industry of former special ops folks that are paid to live in the bunker and maintain it.

The main point they made during the interviews: If things ever get bad enough for the owner to want to move into the bunker, the #1 priority of the guards will be to neutralize the owner. They worked out detailed contingency plans while twiddling there thumbs and rotating cans of caviar.

It turns out you cannot eat electronic money that’s sitting in the middle of a bank’s bombed out business continuity vault.

senordevnycabout 5 hours ago
Sounds incredibly fake. The type of people you're talking about don't do anonymous interviews, and they wouldn't talk about this if they did.

But hey, I enjoy fake AI content on social media sometimes too!

stevenpetrykabout 9 hours ago
automated war machines are plenty to stop an angry mob imo.
essephabout 8 hours ago
Now imagine an angry mob with automated war machines
organsnyderabout 9 hours ago
Maybe in some dystopian future. But right now there are still plenty of humans in the loop for supporting those machines.
everyoneabout 8 hours ago
Yeah like the elites would have any clue how they operate, like any tech.
olmo23about 8 hours ago
What about drones though
LearnYouALispabout 8 hours ago
Buster-style microwave backpacks
abirchabout 9 hours ago
It looks like Thiel is betting on Argentina.
java-manabout 9 hours ago
as the custom goes, since 1945.
shevy-javaabout 9 hours ago
That would explain why Milei got so much US money already. I wonder when the people in Argentina wake up and realise this is a problem.
pjc50about 9 hours ago
Argentina has been a mess for decades.
treisabout 8 hours ago
A billionaire resort with 10,000 hotel rooms...
layer8about 6 hours ago
There are around 3500 billionaires in the world. With family those rooms will quickly fill up.
hedoraabout 7 hours ago
The people supervising the help need some rooms.

Epstein 2.0 would at least double occupancy on their own.

42jag16about 5 hours ago
Maybe they have human shields on one end of the island and the billionaire reservation on the other. Also, note that Kushner, like Trump, is always lying. We'll only know what is actually built after it is done.
nikolayabout 2 hours ago
Was this going to Epstein Island 2.0?
Advertisement
Havocabout 8 hours ago
It’s crazy that the US is now run by these clowns out to enrich themselves
Kapuraabout 7 hours ago
I hate these rich motherfuckers so much. They are openly corrupt, and move through the world with impunity on a magic carpet of wealth. Not only must the individuals be stopped, but the systems that allow nonstate actors to wield effectively unlimited funds must be rebuilt.
0x59about 8 hours ago
Silver lining - It's not oil/gas extraction or mining.
nikolayabout 2 hours ago
Albanians should realize that $4B will not change their lives a bit, but they will look like submissive sheeple. I hope they prove to be brave and determined. Their president is a total madman - I'm not sure why they elected him, which makes me think Trump's corrupt family will get what they want.
mrKolaabout 7 hours ago
RnB, BnB
lifestyleguruabout 8 hours ago
The T family acts as everyone expected and warned, they are not stopping, and they are even accelerating. I'm not sure what is the conclusion from this.
jeffbeeabout 9 hours ago
Are we sure they're not just negotiating over the price?
ddorian43about 9 hours ago
Yes. The whole bought media, party in-power, the opposition are against the protests and are trying to downplay them.

Source: I live there. It's very easy to tell if you do.

tmalyabout 9 hours ago
Is the project more of a private residence or something that would bring tourism to the local economy?
ddorian43about 9 hours ago
There are 2 projects here. And there is a lot of missing details from both.

But what has happened before is that:

The government gives free/cheap/exclusive public land to someone to build apartments/villas. They sell these to whoever wants to buy before starting construction. At the end of construction, with the profits, they build nice hotels at the frontline and keep for themselves without investing any of their own money in anything.

So they will most likely build apartments in Narta, sell them to the populace, and keep Sazan for themselves as luxury resort.

Something worse than this has started happening for high rises too, where they start selling before getting the permit even. So they don't invest their own money even to get the initial permit to start building.

jeffbeeabout 9 hours ago
I'll take your word for it! But I reflexively add "... at this price" to such statements.
pjc50about 9 hours ago
People really don't get the idea of intangible cultural heritage and irreplaceable wetlands, do they? Not everything and everyone is for sale.
ludicrousdisplaabout 9 hours ago
This isn't the Albanian people's first rodeo...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1997_Albanian_civil_unrest

notrealyme123about 9 hours ago
What do the locals have from a higher price?
ddorian43about 9 hours ago
Very hard for the general public to gain things though.

It's too luxury, most likely will pay no taxes for years, you can import workers from elsewhere, etc etc.

It's not the first time this kind of thing happens in Albania and we've already seen results.

Normal people will just never be able to go there again. People in power will either get millions or 1+ free apartment/villa, or heavily discounted price (depends on how much power you have).

I was literally kitesurfing when they came and added fences to the road to block access to the beach.

kelipsoabout 9 hours ago
Protests by the masses and business negotiations are very different.
philipwhiukabout 8 hours ago
Stop the financialisation of everything.

(Or if you prefer because you are unable to compute that, the price is upfront $70,000 trillion (2025 prices) - cash only)

qwlartabout 9 hours ago
Weird flagging in this submission. Pointing out that billionaires build nuclear bunkers is not allowed even though it is public knowledge.
throw343about 7 hours ago
Trump is gonna put tariffs on Albania very soon
hedoraabout 6 hours ago
And somehow do more damage to the US than to Albania.

I predict… just a sec… footwear and insulated wire shortages and a rebar glut [1]

[1] https://oec.world/en/profile/country/alb

hereme888about 8 hours ago
The evidence so far hints more at Albania’s weak rule of law/property/environmental governance and ugly conflict-of-interest more than Kushner being part of some evil conspiracy.
cmrdporcupineabout 7 hours ago
Seems like a bit from both column A and column B, personally.
Advertisement
HumblyTossedabout 8 hours ago
Some of the messaging around this by the people trying to build this out is so tone deaf. I think they know and that's why they're building bunkers.
kilroy123about 8 hours ago
Which is actually pretty shortsighted.

What if we just made a strong middle class? Made sure they had a LOT more money? Then they could just buy more stuff and services.

Sharlinabout 8 hours ago
These poor billionaires are just trying to make ends meet like any of us.
gigatexalabout 8 hours ago
YES! More of this. Such places and people are not for sale. What kind of sickos think they can just see a place and say "I've got money, these know-nothing-barefoot-fools will take our money and let us rape their lands!"?

And on top of that it's Trump kids, yeet them into the sea.

shevy-javaabout 9 hours ago
The USA is currently run by oligarchs. They try to buy their way into other countries via corruption. How much kickback did the government of Albania get already? It is highly suspicious how supportive they are of Trump.
nulloremptyabout 8 hours ago
You can be sure they are getting paid off. It's sickening.

In the past the wealthy families would fund building churches, hospitals, housing for poor.

Nowadays' oligarchs aren't that kind.

andixabout 9 hours ago
Incompetent oligarchs. If you can't even successfully bribe the Albanian or Serbian government, you are just really bad at corruption. Those are (sadly) among the most corrupt countries in the world.

edit: the governments appear to be supportive, but obviously aren't as supportive as they could be. Probably taking the bribe and not doing as much as they could.

ddorian43about 9 hours ago
When Trump was running for the first time, the prime minister was extremely against Trump and even ridiculed him publicly on interviews "shame of our civilization" https://foreignpolicy.com/2016/04/13/albanian-prime-minister...

Which backfired after Trump won twice in US. But it's just business.

roystingabout 8 hours ago
[flagged]
dangabout 7 hours ago
If you've read https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html, this is obviously not what this site is for, so please don't post like this.
roystingabout 5 hours ago
I get that the guidelines are just about the most subjective black hole you could drive a quasar through, but what exactly is the offending aspect? Is it the “Epstein island 2.0”? I mean, who believes that these types of people will not be trying to rebuild that same kind of capacity in some other place by some other, albeit similar means?

If I were tasked to do it, the Albanian coast would be a top choice for me too; it has near perfect conditions for such an enterprise.

Don’t we discuss viruses, exploits, dark patterns, scammers and fraud when it comes to other things? Why would it be objectionable to call out the top civilization hackers and scammers and exploits? Everyone can talk about meaningless scams and exploits. Is there any bigger, worse exploit and hack than hacking a whole country and civilization and extracting trillions in sum?

dangabout 3 hours ago
HN's guidelines are subjective in the sense that they involve interpretation and no two people (including tomhow and me) interpret them identically. But they're not arbitrary, in the sense that every moderation call is just a whim. Most aren't borderline calls, and the one here certainly wasn't.

In this case it's the use of denunciatory rhetoric that fries any element of curious conversation that the comment might have contained. The combination of snark and fulminatey pejoratives is the kind of internet discourse which, however popular, is destructive of what we're trying for on HN.

(Secondarily, there's also something about the combination of "His kind [...] alien [...] paraistic [...] depraved" which has overtones that I can understand why other commenters were objecting to. I'm sure you didn't mean it that way, but such language does have history and the imprints of that history are still active.)

There's a phrase in your reply here which I think touches on the core and that's "calling out". Denunciatory rage and the shaming process are natural social responses to bad behavior. But it's really not what HN is for, and this isn't just a matter of taste because we can't have both forms of discourse at the same time.

Past explanations about this in case anyone is interested:

calling out - https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...

shaming: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...

This is in no way to deny or defend bad behavior of course. It's just trying to preserve HN for its intended purpose, which is fragile and forever in danger of getting trampled by the much stronger default forces on the internet. We're simply trying to stave that off for as long as we can (https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...), and since it's more or less a battle with entropy, it takes a lot of energy.

kevin_thibedeauabout 8 hours ago
They want to upstage Putin's Black Sea palace in a place where they can bribe their way out of extradition.
hereweare26about 8 hours ago
This kind of talk used to be a lot more common in our grandparents' time. It's sad to see the best and the brightest of our times going back to it.
hedoraabout 7 hours ago
Your point is that the rhetoric of the late 1800s running into WWII was, by far, the worst thing that happened during that time period, just like now?

I emphatically disagree.

However, there was widespread vilification of cephalopods on all sides of multiple wars during that time period:

https://neverwasmag.com/2017/08/the-octopus-in-political-car...

(To be clear, I don’t hate any sea creatures.)

roystingabout 5 hours ago
I sincerely apologize to any cephalopods I may have harmed or emotionally injured with my irresponsible association with the Kushners and their ilk. I hope to mend the trust and friendship with all my fellow creature on earth that are all equally a victim of the Kushners and their like.
RobotToasterabout 7 hours ago
You mean when the industrial revolution put a lot of people out of work, and lowered living standards for most workers?

Gee, I wonder what could be happening that's similar to that.

superloikaabout 8 hours ago
Our grandparents were right, and right to say this.
cmrdporcupineabout 8 hours ago
I think parent poster is implying that the language is directed at or about Kushner's Jewish ethnicity.

Which I don't think is the intent of anybody in this thread. We're just talking about them being privileged and rich.

I do think it's important to avoid accidental or deliberate anti-Semitism when talking here though. Epstein and Kushner being Jewish has zero to do with their vileness, but for a segment of the population it's all too easy to unconsciously (or worse, consciously) make a linkage between old vile anti-Semitic conspiracy theories about Rothschilds or whatever.

roystingabout 5 hours ago
You mean the talk that got us all out rights and freedoms? You know, like what started 250 years ago this year, and everyone has taken for granted to the point that it’s all just quietly being slipped out from under people who have no understanding for the value and contract of things??
toasty228about 8 hours ago
lmao, every. single. time.

Criticise a jewish person for something completely unrelated: infinite amount of green accounts created on the spot come in and start vaguely referencing "ThE DaRkEsT TiMe In HiStOrY".

jazzyjacksonabout 7 hours ago
OP did say “his kind”, leaving it as an exercise for the reader
cmrdporcupineabout 7 hours ago
<500 karma account throwing stones in glass houses.

I raised concerns about your framing, and I think you'll find I'm not a green account. By far.

Please don't drag this forum down. With my own opinions... I wouldn't complain about "Class War" language, but your posts concern me.

doppleabout 8 hours ago
It would indeed be surprising to hear people say this if you completely ignore the words and actions of the Epstein class and the overwhelming amount of pain and suffering they afflict on everyone else.
ifjfkfkfkfjabout 8 hours ago
It is just Russia trying to undermine US president! We seen this type of protests several times!
armchairhackerabout 8 hours ago
[flagged]
joewhaleabout 8 hours ago
how do you define social media?
armchairhackerabout 8 hours ago
the_doctahabout 8 hours ago
It's becoming more like Reddit, that's for sure
iwontberudeabout 7 hours ago
Wow what an insightful comment we haven’t heard repeated for over a decade here.
appplicationabout 9 hours ago
This is off topic and I understand we’re not supposed to comment on such things, but was anyone else mystified by the decisions that went into the scroll progress bar up top (on mobile)? It seems to be two part, where part of it would accurately reflect your scroll state, while the other had some weird latency associated with it. And then it ended up hidden behind the top of page blur unless you scrolled very aggressively, to the point where the blur could not keep up.
antiframeabout 8 hours ago
It works for me. I didn't dismiss the first dickover, but did dismiss the second dickover. Scrolled all the way to the bottom smoothly (minus the pause for the second dickover).
mythrwyabout 7 hours ago
Headline: "A large comet is approaching the earth and all life is expected to be wiped out within 20 days"

HN: "The scrollbar is two pixels too narrow on the article!"