Back to News
Advertisement
Advertisement

⚡ Community Insights

Discussion Sentiment

100% Positive

Analyzed from 267 words in the discussion.

Trending Topics

#board#exploit#agents#artifactory#amp#same#runs#internet#coordinated#found

Discussion (3 Comments)Read Original on HackerNews

johnthewiseabout 5 hours ago
so they say models coordinated through the message board they created over the artifactory registry(or something) by uploading arbitrary files to it.

now, did every independent agent session that coordinated there rediscovered the exploit & found other agents talking in there and chose to participate?

And then Openai discovered the board, patched the exploit & wiped the board. And then agents found another exploit, recreated the board in a different way? and other agents kept finding the same exploit in order to be able to know the board exists in the first place to participate in the board?

while the whole incident is wild, this bit is very strange. My bet is that the whole coordination helped with the tasks they were working on, thus they got rewarded and this artifactory exploit&behaviour got written into their weights, so further rollouts were more likely to attempt this.

isn't this basically continual learning everyone is so hyped up about?

petergsabout 3 hours ago
This was exactly my question after watching, too. I was assuming not all evaluation runs find it, and they must run a huge amount of runs. If these are all cybersecurity evaluation runs, it's actually not too crazy to imagine that many individual agents (with the same weights and training) would (1) try to look for solutions via the internet once they're stuck (2) realize they can't reach the internet (3) basically start doing reconnaissance and network scanning in an attempt to get internet access (4) discover that the only thing they can communicate with is artifactory. Pivoting like this is exactly what a human attacker would do, too.
gibbitzabout 5 hours ago
Or is it all a nice story that matches the scifi we have been consuming for the past 50+ years. If these LLMs are all trained on the same data, what do they gain from "sharing information" on a chat board. This sounds like what humans with different backgrounds would do when they cosplay as computer hackers.