Back to News
Advertisement
Advertisement

⚡ Community Insights

Discussion Sentiment

0% Positive

Analyzed from 329 words in the discussion.

Trending Topics

#libraries#school#books#public#banned#book#library#article#call#prevented

Discussion (20 Comments)Read Original on HackerNews

smithoc•about 2 hours ago
Important to note that "banned" here means "a school chose not to have this book in their library".

It's an annoying abuse of language. "Banned Books" has historically meant people are getting arrested for possessing the books or stores are being prevented from selling it or publishers are being prevented from producing it.

This is essentially a clickbait title for "People disagree about what is age-appropriate content for a public school to provide to children".

torben-friis•about 2 hours ago
Depends on your definition of people:

>The report also found that challenges are becoming more coordinated and politically driven: 92% came from pressure groups, decision-makers or government officials, compared with 72% in 2024. By contrast, 2.7% were attributed to parents and 1.4% to individual library users.

So this isn't librarians, parents or even neighbours deciding something isn't appropriate.

The article also seems to refer to libraries in general, as opposed to school libraries alone, except on a specific paragraph.

rahimnathwani•26 minutes ago
Why do you assume librarians aren't part of the 'government official's group?
like_any_other•about 1 hour ago
The article is indeed very careful to never tell us how much of this is school libraries.
KumaBear•14 minutes ago
I mean you can find scripture and if anyone has read that it’s not for children. Yet no objections
ImPostingOnHN•about 2 hours ago
This is incorrect. The article is talking about book bans at public libraries and school libraries alike.

The linked censorship search portal [0] lets you filter by "# Count of Challenges at Public Libraries" > 0.

0 – https://www.ala.org/bbooks/censorship-search-portal

barbazoo•about 1 hour ago
I'd call that "not making publicly available" via the library system rather than banning. As parent said, you can still buy these books and share with or sell them to each other.
ImPostingOnHN•about 1 hour ago
I'd call it "banning books from public libraries", since that's a clear description. Contrary to what GP claimed, this is indeed public libraries, not just school libraries.

Whatever you want to call it, IMO public libraries shouldn't ban books, especially based on some radical PAC's opinions about what jesus would want or whatever.

yeah879846•about 1 hour ago
List?
like_any_other•about 1 hour ago
Camp of the Saints by Jean Raspail, or White Identity by Jared Taylor, never make these banned book lists. They don't have to be "banned" - libraries simply make them unavailable, so they get to control information, without being the kind of horrible people that would censor or ban a book. How virtuous!
cyanydeez•about 2 hours ago
We wont need books in the future. You'll just open up your Red OpenAI or Blue Claude app and ask it for a new story !
KumaBear•12 minutes ago
No you will tell it make X into a live action tv show.