Back to News
Advertisement
Advertisement

⚡ Community Insights

Discussion Sentiment

50% Positive

Analyzed from 267 words in the discussion.

Trending Topics

#data#state#access#database#driver#federal#feds#subpoena#license#ncic

Discussion (16 Comments)Read Original on HackerNews

giantg2•about 1 hour ago
The author is concerned that the feds could subpoena the data from the company that it's being submitted to. Wouldn't this same concern apply to the feds serving a subpoena to the state? Once the data is out there, it's out there. If one level of government has it, all the peer/higher levels will have access of they want it.

It sounds like this database is the one that feeds license data to NCIC. The bigger question here is if we should be compiling and using data in the NCIC suchbas driver licenses and carry permits.

iamnothere•about 1 hour ago
States can and do resist federal subpoenas and have more leeway in doing so. They also have enormous legal resources.
m-hodges•about 1 hour ago
Roughly 9 years ago: https://neveragain.tech/
chopete3•20 minutes ago
This is a very good pledge to have all humans to sign up for anywhere on the globe.

>>We are choosing to stand in solidarity with Muslim Americans,

This particular word, with no other identities after that, takes the air out of this massive effort and gives the impression it is a localized effort.

johng•about 2 hours ago
The article doesn't seem to go into any discussion or reasoning why Gavin Newsom would want to cooperate with this, seemingly against his own party?

What are the downsides of not cooperating? What is his motivation or benefits for capitulating?

Edit: Oh, ahhh I see: "Governor Gavin Newsom agreed to upload driver's license data to a national database primarily to comply with the Real ID Act of 2005 and avoid federal threats that would prevent California IDs from being accepted at airports and other federal facilities. This decision was finalized through a budget compromise with the state legislature following intense pressure from the U.S. Department of Homeland Security"

sandworm101•about 1 hour ago
Article has bad title.

"about all driver’s licenses and ID cards"

This isnt just about drivers. That matters. Driving a car is not a fundamental right. But access to a state ID card, something you will need to access many services, probably is.

Sjeiti•about 2 hours ago
That is fitting: "Error establishing a database connection"