Back to News
Advertisement
Advertisement

⚡ Community Insights

Discussion Sentiment

60% Positive

Analyzed from 518 words in the discussion.

Trending Topics

#pdf#page#browser#open#form#tools#files#device#network#don

Discussion (15 Comments)Read Original on HackerNews

gettalongabout 3 hours ago
Why is it that everyone now duplicates/vibe-codes PDF tool websites? It seems that there is one new each week for about half a year now with none providing any outstanding features over the others.
jamessb6 minutes ago
This one's website (and a dead comment replying to you) suggests that processing the PDF in the browser, rather than uploading to a server, is a point of differentiation.

However, there are older tools that do this, such as BentoPDF (which is also open source) [1].

[1]: https://www.bentopdf.com/

cyanydeezabout 3 hours ago
theyre the AI todo app: sufficiently complex and mildly useful. will fail when real use case outstrips its minimum depth.
hasudon7171about 1 hour ago
To me, it looks like a design generated by AI. It had exactly the same vibe as those kinds of sites I see all the time.
fp64about 2 hours ago
Which library did you compile to WASM for this? I doubt this is a from scratch implementation of full PDF
sscaryterryabout 7 hours ago
Where is the company registered? None of these details are on your website.
pdfmergelyabout 6 hours ago
Fair point, I'll add an About/Contact page with who's behind it.

It's a small solo project; there's no company entity yet, but also no account or server, so nothing of yours is collected — files are processed in your browser and never leave your device (verifiable in the Network tab).

sscaryterryabout 6 hours ago
No one is going to take your word at face value. Assume people don't know how to open the developer tools.
pdfmergelyabout 6 hours ago
A good point . open the Network tab" isn't a real answer for most people, and "trust me" isn't either.

Two things that don't depend on either: (1) the offline test is something anyone can do ,load the page, turn off your wifi, and the tools keep working, which they couldn't if they relied on a server; (2) the site ships a Content-Security-Policy that blocks outbound connections, so it's the browser enforcing it, not my word. The real fix for trust is open-sourcing it and getting a third-party audit, which is on my list.

Appreciate you pushing on this.

steveharrisonabout 6 hours ago
Love the idea, but would help trustworthiness if the design looked a little less vibe-coded.
jimjimjimabout 4 hours ago
Question about merging: How do you handle merging multiple pdf that have forms? Are the form fields renamed to prevent form field name clashes?

And what pdf toolkit do you use?

pdfmergelyabout 3 hours ago
Our merge is page-level, not form-aware. We copy the pages (including the visual appearance of form fields), but we don't merge the PDFs' AcroForm dictionaries.

As a result, form fields typically aren't fillable after merging, and field name conflicts aren't an issue, so we don't rename fields.

We use @cantoo/pdf-lib (a maintained fork of pdf-lib) running entirely client-side in a Web Worker, so all processing happens locally in the browser and no files leave the user's device.

pdfmergelyabout 7 hours ago
Author here. Quick note on how the "no upload" claim actually works, since it deserves scrutiny.

There's no upload endpoint to send files to. When you pick a file, the browser hands the app the bytes directly; the work runs in a Web Worker on your device, with WebAssembly for the heavier parts like encryption. The finished PDF is built locally and downloaded. The page is also locked down with a strict CSP so file data has no network path out — you can open the Network tab and confirm nothing leaves while you work. After the first load it works fully offline, which is the easiest proof.

The honest tradeoff: because everything runs on your device, very large files depend on your machine's memory and a phone won't match a desktop. We process a page at a time to keep memory in check.

Tools today: merge, split, reorder, rotate, delete/extract pages, compress, watermark, page numbers, protect/unlock. Free, no sign-up. Would love feedback on what to add next.

da-xabout 2 hours ago
Perhaps you can also provide a Tauri-based independent downloadable app.