Back to News
Advertisement
Advertisement

⚡ Community Insights

Discussion Sentiment

70% Positive

Analyzed from 993 words in the discussion.

Trending Topics

#glue#adhesive#ptfe#hot#hand#don#things#non#stuff#magnets

Discussion (29 Comments)Read Original on HackerNews

murderfs•about 1 hour ago
> “Since ethanol is the main component of hand sanitizer, we believe it is possible to de-bond and recycle the adhesive by using hand sanitizer as a substitute in certain real-world situations,” Aida says.

These sorts of environmental impact blurbs are hilarious. What kind of scenario are they envisioning where someone wants to remove and reuse a specialized adhesive bonding PTFE parts to something, but don't have ethanol on hand and have to fall back to using hand sanitizer?

gizmo686•16 minutes ago
Who says this will be a specialized adhesive? If it works as advertised, it could be a super-glue alternative with easy unglueability. That would be an attractive consumer product; and the type of product that could easily end up on someones hands.
loeg•30 minutes ago
Hand sanitizer is also contaminated with other crap... presumably that impacts the adhesive if you're attempting to "recycle" it? I agree, what a weird line.
mint5•17 minutes ago
Yay more sources of weird forever chemicals. And while it’s been a long time since ochem, there’s quite a few places this molecule looks like it can break apart.

They should show results form oxidation, thermal stability, accelerated aging tests.

And I’m beyond skeptical anyone would carefully recover this gunk each even once for re-use outside some contrived lab demo.

oflannabhra•about 1 hour ago
I guess one of my favorite old-school websites will need to get updated, ThisToThat [0].

[0] - https://www.thistothat.com

DannyBee•about 1 hour ago
This website often suggests totally bad ideas, like brittle epoxies for bonds they shouldn't be used for.

The truth is nowadays you can just choose your favorite brand and they almost certainly have a correct, and good, adhesive selector.

For example, for loctite, you should just use: https://www.henkel-adhesives-selector.com/

oflannabhra•about 1 hour ago
maybe, but where is the whimsy or delight in that?
BenjiWiebe•8 minutes ago
Not a lot of whimsy and delight in having your glue joint fail because the delightful & whimsical website gave bad advice.
ble•about 1 hour ago
Interesting that it seems like the application method is to melt the glue:

> To test its adhesive strength, researchers first glued two untreated polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) plates by sandwiching molten CyclicFP-fmoc between them and letting it cool at room temperature for 10 min.

Also notable that the glue substance is reusable:

> Remarkably, a simple ethanol wash completely stripped CyclicFP-fmoc from the target PTFE plates, leaving no trace behind. The recovered adhesive proved repeatedly reusable, reliably maintaining its adhesive strength of ~1.2 ± 0.1 MPa across multiple cycles.

Perhaps hot glue guns are going to get an update ;)

bombela•29 minutes ago
For anybody not getting the reference, standard glue gun glue is obviously applied freshly melted and hot, and it is dissolved/debonded cleanly with isopropyl alcohol.
teddyh•16 minutes ago

  s/^/This /
bilsbie•29 minutes ago
Could this be used for hanging things from walls without damaging them?
bertjk•41 minutes ago
At the risk of asking a really dumb question: Does this only work on PTFE or other flourine-compound surfaces?
coldbrewed•33 minutes ago
IANA chemist but my guess is that it's of particular interest because PTFE surfaces are especially non-stick, and non-PTFE surfaces have good options that require less exotic chemistry.

The question I have is how long will it be till the report comes out indicating that DuPont has been dumping this product and intermediate compounds into local waterways. I give it 15 years?

ssl-3•about 1 hour ago
I'm very impressed that they were able to use glue on PTFE for...approximately anything at all. That's impressive.

But I'd like to take this opportunity to present my semi-annual rant about hot glue, instead.

It's amazing stuff. It's similar to many other liquid adhesives in that you can stick things together with it (probably not PTFE, but...), and they stay pretty well stuck.

But it's got this really neat property that most other things lack: When used with non-porous surfaces, it's removable. A few drops of isopropyl alcohol will eek in between the glue and the surface it is stuck to. It stays solid, but basically just falls right off with no apparent mess.

...which makes it absolutely fantastic for temporary fixturing.

Like: Glue an accelerometer to the middle of the 3D printer bed for resonance tuning using a very thin layer of hot glue, and then just use a bit of isopropyl to take it off later. It's like it never happened.

bluGill•40 minutes ago
There are many different hot glues, not all have that property.
ssl-3•18 minutes ago
TIL.

Which ones have this property, and which ones do not? How do we tell them apart?

How do I identify the cheap hot glue that came with the cheap hot glue gun that I bought at Dollar General on a Saturday afternoon in 2021? It does this business just fine.

gertop•1 minute ago
The ones that don't have the property are expensive specialized/stronger glue sticks. If you stick to dollar general you don't have to think about it.
oasisbob•about 1 hour ago
Isn't high-ductility associated with creep, especially under static loads? That would seem to be a downside of an adhesive like this.
pavel_lishin•about 3 hours ago
My mind immediately jumped to The Mote In God's Eye.
squigz•about 1 hour ago
In what context would one re-use a glue like this?
DannyBee•about 1 hour ago
I have a weird use case, but this is actually wildly useful to me.

I use teflon (sometimes nylon, but mostly teflon) painter pyramids/holders/etc, because i spray finish stuff that is very good at adhering to lots of things, and are acetone based - VOC compliance pretty much forced acetone into solvent based stuff. This in turn pretty much makes finishes melt into anything except PE, nylon, teflon, even if they wouldn't otherwise.

To keep the pyramids and things where i want them, i have magnets glued into them. But because it's PFTE, the magnets don't really stay adhered well, even with (currently) specialized adhesives and i end up regluing them after every few times, often before the project finishes.

What i really want is an adhesive like this one, where i can glue the magnets in, but also remove them after the project finishes, because i'll go soak the pyramids in solvent or something to clean them, but don't want to damage any magnet coatings.

bombela•17 minutes ago
I would 3D print (FDM) standoffs in PE with integrated pockets to insert magnets. You can even insert the magnets during the print if you fancy. Though my preference goes to a slide in pocket.

PE sticks to itself and not much else. Packing tape is PE and adhesive. Apply PE tape to the printer bed before printing.

Advertisement
butvacuum•about 2 hours ago
Is there really a use for this(temporary adhesives) outside of Fixturing?
jesperwe•about 2 hours ago
The marine industry would love a (non water soluble) glue that achieves structural strength on PTFE and POM.
TeMPOraL•about 2 hours ago
Are you asking if there's use for temporarily sticking stuff to other stuff?

Yes, plenty. Especially if it sticks well while needed, and then can be non-destructively undone when no longer needed.

bluGill•about 2 hours ago
That is generally what fixturing implies. A temporary bond that you use while making a part, and then remove when the part is complete.
lotu•about 1 hour ago
I think it could also be used outside of making a part. For example you want to setup sensor on a surface but it's important not to damage the surface, like the outside of a boat. This would be excellent for that.
baxuz•about 2 hours ago
This might be very useful for bonding PTFE and aluminium on cookware if it ends up being food safe.
dcrazy•about 2 hours ago
Any reason to think this flower of fluorines (seriously, that thing looks INTENSE) would be any more environmentally safe than PFOA?
yk•about 2 hours ago
On the left hand side we see a lot very unhappy carbon.