Back to News
Advertisement
Advertisement

⚡ Community Insights

Discussion Sentiment

42% Positive

Analyzed from 1499 words in the discussion.

Trending Topics

#microsoft#windows#account#don#company#desktop#mac#software#every#office

Discussion (26 Comments)Read Original on HackerNews

Scharkenberg•about 2 hours ago
Henrique should take it up to his university. When I was a student, mine used to provide me with an account that could use desktop apps on Windows and Mac. Educational institutions get very cheap license bundles compared to enterprises btw.

(Also funny that he says we should not use proprietary software, but ignores his own usage of macOS.)

stuartd•about 2 hours ago
> Please stop using windows. Please stop using proprietary document formats.
janalsncm•about 2 hours ago
The point is that OS specific licenses shouldn’t exist. Especially when Microsoft makes Word and Windows.
bjt12345•about 2 hours ago
I think one of the more insane things Microsoft have done is their product management of MS Visio.

It became so insanely expensive my work started making us apply for 3 month licenses until we gave up and found something else.

About 15 years ago my Industry was using MS Visio for every diagram.

But they updated the GUI entirely and nobody could be bothered with the new format.

Now people use DrawIO and MS Visio is forgotten.

lopsotronic•18 minutes ago
About ten years ago I went with text-based graph description languages and haven't looked back[1].

One application of AI I have found useful is in the quick composition of graphs via text-based graph description languages: graphviz (the great granddaddy), mermaid.js, plantuml, and of course derivatives like WireViz and CircuiTikZ.

A typical ask would be something like "generate a mermaid network diagram showing the relationships of all markup languages". It's surprisingly good.

A neat trick you can do if writing in Asciidoc: conditional directives are pre-processor directives, which means they're interpreted before the graphing engine goes to work. So you can make art that has sections which can toggle on and off based on document variables (the Asciidoc lingo for these is "attributes" but using that word can be confusing for old XML hands). Very neat when you have a block diagram you want to reuse for lots of different configurations.

[1] Unless I need 3d, in which case I'm afraid I like Blender a lot. Even more than Asciidoc.

briangray•about 1 hour ago
Similar story. We moved to DrawIO desktop. I now also use it as a replacement for whiteboarding and have it open in most meetings.
kown7•about 2 hours ago
I don't know what you're doing and I feel all of your Visio pain, but have you tried typst?
jadbox•about 2 hours ago
I do like Typst, but Typst isn't really ideal for diagrams... you could use it that way but I don't think it's ideal. Mermaid or PlantUML are better/cleaner options.
0x1ch•about 1 hour ago
Agreed. My resume and slides are all templated with Typst, but I can't be bothered trying UML languages to make diagrams that'll probably be referenced once or twice a year, if ever.
vondur•about 2 hours ago
It looks like your license only allows for the web version, so your university probably isn't spending that much for it. You'd get the same message on Windows too.
nrub•about 2 hours ago
I think this overlooks the full picture. It's not about the this one pin prick relating to their license. It's that working with Microsoft in any capacity is filled with paper cuts like this, annoyances, bad design, and overt errors. Every single day.

They're a User hostile company and they make a buck by doing just enough to convince non-experts to keep their enterprise licenses.

bunderbunder•about 2 hours ago
Though, that's true of every single Microsoft-sized B2B-focused company I've ever encountered, as well as the one I once worked at.

I honestly would not attribute it to malice. I would attribute it to the scale of the company and the nature of the business they're in. A behemoth this size naturally has the "left hand doesn't know what the right one is doing" problem on an unfathomable scale simply because it's far too big for any one person to keep track of more than a small fraction of everything.

And then throw on top of it that they have a whole bunch of enterprise clients who can exert an incredible amount of pressure on individual decision makers. And there will never, ever be a Steve Jobs like figure who's willing to help them hold the line against that in the name of a sensible and coherent overall product vision because maintaining a sensible and coherent overall product vision does not generate positive ROI for this kind of company. Microsoft tried to have one several times during its "envious of Apple" days and every time the enterprise customers who actually supply their revenue responded by swatting them on the nose with a rolled up newspaper.

internet101010•about 2 hours ago
Windows 11 has been out for like 6 years and they still haven't fixed a major File Explorer bug: after a few minutes of File Explorer being open the menu bar for the old File Explorer pops up underneath the new thing that replace the menu bar; none of the buttons on this weird artifact from the past work. It's just there. Re-open File Explorer and it goes away, until a few minutes later and it re-appears.

Not as noticeable on light mode but a constant distracting reminder about how much Microslop sucks on dark mode.

WalterBright•about 2 hours ago
Should have stayed with Windows 7!
bunderbunder•about 2 hours ago
I'm not so sure about that. For a while now I've worked at companies where PC users could use desktop Office but Mac users had to use the Web version. I think that Office for Mac might actually be a largely separate codebase - there are also significant feature differences between it and the PC version.

Also, just quickly poking through their various enterprise plans (https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/microsoft-365/enterprise/mic...), I found several that offered Web & Windows but not Mac, and none that only allowed editing on Web like you describe.

bibstha•about 2 hours ago
Silly that the error message doesn't convey that, right? I recently got added to a company's Teams account as a guest. I do a bit of software contract work and have used Slack with no issue until now, this is what Teams show me:

- Client says they added me already, but I have no email with an invite. Turns out I didn't have an account that had previously joined Teams with a personal account.

- But even after I created a teams account, due to the order of events (added to corp account as guest, then created a teams account), I still don't have access and need to be readded.

- I can't upload images on groups because I don't have OneDrive access, WTF?

- I cannot download transcripts of meetings I join because I don't have permission.

How bad can a software be? Really?

legitster•about 2 hours ago
This is more about the Office 365 admin configuration settings than about Microsoft's products themselves.

"Why do people still buy Microsoft?" Because admins can make weird configuration settings.

yndoendo•about 2 hours ago
You have to pay me to use Microsoft products and services.

The user experience gets worse with each passing year. A good product designer would see numerous flaws with in five minutes of using their office suite.

johnsmith1840•about 2 hours ago
I recently was building out on azure and oh boy, the joy of microsoft products.

Their troubleshoot support tool must be the same team that makes it on local windows troubleshooter because literally every single time you use it, it spins for 10min then says it can't fix anything.

vinni2•about 2 hours ago
> You have to pay me to use Microsoft products and services.

I had this same attitude and boy did they pay me (or my startup) to use azure, they gave us shit load of free credits I couldn’t resist.

But at the same time my university is forcing us to use Exchange for email. I have no way around that and Office 365 and Teams are default softwares. I hate it but I can’t do anything about it.

WalterBright•about 2 hours ago
How can they force you to not use Thunderbird mail? If I use Thunderbird mail to send an email to an Exchange user, would it be blocked? How about vice versa?
jadar•about 2 hours ago
First, doesn't Microsoft give away M365 for free to educational institutions? (Perhaps that's only US institutions, though.) Second, isn't this how they bill their accounts — Business Basic doesn't get desktop apps and you need to pay more to use desktop apps? Third, did the OP try to open their document in LibreOffice? I think there's a legitimate criticism of the move from one-time lifetime purchases to the SaaS economy, but Microsoft isn't the only one who deserves criticism for this.
saulpw•about 2 hours ago
Perhaps Microsoft is the biggest one though? (Who could possibly be bigger?)
jadar•about 2 hours ago
Perhaps Google would be bigger? They don't even have desktop app offerings and the consumer versions are subsidized with your advertising data. They certainly weren't the first to introduce the pattern. I feel like Adobe was one of the first big providers to move from lifetime licenses to subscriptions.
harmlessblu•about 2 hours ago
I've seen this and I think it's actually a bug. I have mac computers at work and occasionally this will crop up and typically signing out and back in resolves the issue.
miamicholo•about 2 hours ago
Outlook is the new Lotus Notes
flowerlad•about 2 hours ago
Outlook for Windows used to be great in the 90s and early 2000s. Since then all they have done is added new bugs. And the latest version is HTML/JavaScript in a WebView, no longer native Windows.
Handy-Man•about 2 hours ago
It seems your plan wouldn't even allow editing on Windows. Your university seems to be just paying for web versions.
jimbobimbo•about 2 hours ago
Alternative headline: my university had bought a (cheaper?) plan which doesn't tick all necessary boxes.
Grombobulous•about 2 hours ago
This is a good time to point out that Microsoft’s tiers and pricing for Microsoft 365 is completely insane as far as the overwhelming number of different ways to fundamentally buy the exact same software.

I realize they’re trying to sell a productivity suite to basically every business on earth and that the complexity might at some point be necessary, but still…could be simpler.

rwz•42 minutes ago
I think the main point is that the existence of this box is a problem, not that someone forgot or deliberately chosen not to tick it.
mrdatawolf•about 2 hours ago
An Apple user complaining about this? Oh that is rich!

I don't condone or like this kind of thing from MS. We all know though who MS copies...

You support the company that perfected it. So pot meet kettle.

jbubimon•about 2 hours ago
Except Apple’s products tend to be at the very least good. The baseline for Microsoft products, however, is unusable.
Advertisement
TutleCpt•about 2 hours ago
I also hate Microsoft.
hosel•about 2 hours ago
What they did to windows is criminal. I honestly cannot believe the state of windows 11. I will never work a job again where I have to use windows.
fooker•about 1 hour ago
The version of windows you get for software development at a company that needs windows for software development is pretty good, no sign of any adware or bloatware, no phoning home, no sus telemetry or updates forced by microsoft.
tombert•about 1 hour ago
It's a soft line in the sand for me as well.

If a job pays really really well, then sure I will run Windows, but short of that I'm going to opt for Mac, or I'm going to try and figure out a way to replace the Windows with a Linux.

jbubimon•about 2 hours ago
Criminal behaviour is in Windows’ very DNA. Microsoft openly taking advantage of its customers and treating them like cattle is perfectly on brand for them. Always has been. Always will be. Windows and Office only gained traction via nefarious acts on Microsoft’s part and now we live in a world where Microsoft is relevant.

Criminal all the way down.

pelagicAustral•about 2 hours ago
Skill issue, this is why I mainline a macbook pro, a windows shitbox laptop and my kubuntu katana mega riced XPS. Yeah, I also walk about with a live cd.
humungus•about 2 hours ago
based